How many QBs would you take before Drew for this season?

[buffmaniac]

According to Buff News, Drew's average salary will rank him 17th among starting NFL QBs. So how many QBs starting on other teams would you take before Bledsoe for this season?

My take:
AFC east
Miami -Fiedler/Feeley NO
Jets -Pennington YES
NE - Brady YES

AFC north
Pitt - Maddox NO
Cin - Palmer NO
Balt - Boller NO
Cle - Garcia Maybe

AFC south
Ind - Manning YES
Tenn - McNair YES
Hou - Carr NO
Jax - Leftwich maybe

AFC west
KC - Green maybe
SD - Rivers/Brees NO
Oak - Gannon NO
Den - Plummer Maybe

NFC west
Arz - McCown NO
STL - Bulger NO
Sea - Hasselback YES
SF - Rattay NO

NFC south
Atl - Vick YES
TB - Johnson NO
Car - Delhomme YES
NO - Brooks Maybe

NFC north
Min - Culpepper YES
GB - Favre YES
Det - Harrington NO
Chi - Grossman NO

NFC east
NY - Manning NO
Was - Brunnell maybe
Phil - McNabb YES
Dal - Carter NO

10 YES
6 Maybe
15 NO

So really Bledsoe would fall somewhere around 12-14 IMO so the 17th salary is pretty fair. What do you guys think?

[Novacane]

most of those guys you marked no next to could do better than 10TDs and 24 turnovers

[buffmaniac]

Originally posted by Fairway To Green
most of those guys you marked no next to could do better than 10TDs and 24 turnovers

Not if they had Gilbride as their OC, if they had their best WR injured, and if they had a struggling OL.

Honestly how many guys would you seriously rather have as our QB next year instead of Drew?

[Novacane]

of your 6 maybes I'd take 5 of them over Drew. I don't like brooks so I'd put him under no.

from your no's I'd say yes to Carr and Harrington. Maybe to Mcnown, Bulger, Johnson,

[buffmaniac]

.

Originally posted by Fairway To Green
of your 6 maybes I'd take 5 of them over Drew. I don't like brooks so I'd put him under no.

from your no's I'd say yes to Carr and Harrington. Maybe to Mcnown, Bulger, Johnson,

That's not a bad assessment. Obviously my maybe guys could go either way.

I would not take Carr or Harrington over Drew at this point. Neither has proven anything yet.

Bulger could be a maybe but McCown and Johnson are definite NOs to me.

Even with your rankings though you still would have Drew as the #17 QB so I guess you think his salary is fair. Or do you?

[Novacane]

Originally posted by buffmaniac
.



Even with your rankings though you still would have Drew as the #17 QB so I guess you think his salary is fair. Or do you?

I guess so if thats what NFL QB's are making. If he plays like the 17th best QB I'll be happy. I can't take anymore #32 ranked QB play like last year

[saviorbledsoe]

Why would u start this Buffmaniac? Some of these guys who are obsessed with bashing Drew are like vulchers looking for anything to strike at.......... but usually end up eating dead Sh@!. :)

[buffmaniac]

Originally posted by Fairway To Green
I guess so if thats what NFL QB's are making. If he plays like the 17th best QB I'll be happy. I can't take anymore #32 ranked QB play like last year

Neither can I. Drew does need to play better. I think the new coaches, the new schemes, getting some players healthy (Moulds/McGahee) and some of the other player additions(Villarrial/Evans) all will help Drew rebound. And if Drew can regain his old form he very possibly could be a top 10 QB this year.

[Novacane]

Originally posted by saviorbledsoe
Why would u start this Buffmaniac? Some of these guys who are obsessed with bashing Drew are like vulchers looking for anything to strike at.......... but usually end up eating dead Sh@!. :)

Unlike you.............most of us can have a Bledsoe discussion without it turning into "bashing"

[saviorbledsoe]

Originally posted by buffmaniac


Neither can I. Drew does need to play better. I think the new coaches, the new schemes, getting some players healthy (Moulds/McGahee) and some of the other player additions(Villarrial/Evans) all will help Drew rebound. And if Drew can regain his old form he very possibly could be a top 10 QB this year.

I totally agree. But 3 people will regurgitate that he "has never been a great qb"

[buffmaniac]

Originally posted by saviorbledsoe
Why would u start this Buffmaniac? Some of these guys who are obsessed with bashing Drew are like vulchers looking for anything to strike at.......... but usually end up eating dead Sh@!. :)

Sorry Savior

I'm hoping that some people will see that Drew is still better than alot of QBs on other teams.

[saviorbledsoe]

Originally posted by Fairway To Green
Unlike you.............most of us can have a Bledsoe discussion without it turning into "bashing"

Originally posted by Fairway To Green
most of those guys you marked no next to could do better than 10TDs and 24 turnovers

You were saying?

[B-DON]

Originally posted by saviorbledsoe
Why would u start this Buffmaniac? Some of these guys who are obsessed with bashing Drew are like vulchers looking for anything to strike at.......... but usually end up eating dead Sh@!. :)

just like your a vulture(spelling?) to strike at anyone who makes even slightest negative remark about bledsoe

[Novacane]

Originally posted by Fairway To Green
most of those guys you marked no next to could do better than 10TDs and 24 turnovers

facts are facts.

[Novacane]

Originally posted by B-DON


just like your a vulture(spelling?) to strike at anyone who makes even slightest negative remark about bledsoe