In what circumstances would you consider trading one of our RBs (WM or TH) for a 1st round pick next year?
1) Both WM and TH do good
2) WM does good TH does okay (some fumbles)
3) TH goes good, WM doesn't show top form
4) Both WM and TH do bad
The good thing is the Bills like Shaud Williams. Along with Joe Burns, our RB backfield is way too crowded. They may need to get rid of one regardless.
If you had to pick, which one would you pick to go based on the scenarios above?
My opinion:
1) If they both do good, keep TH. He's shown he's a warrior (and is cheap). Of course, WM is younger...it may depend on how good each one was and how close in performance they were...
2) if WM does better, trade TH - perhaps back to Dallas for our pick back. If you think about it, we come out winning on that. Dallas traded their 1st round pick to us and we got Losman to train for a year and add some knowledge and experience to his belt. In turn, we got to keep TH for a year before giving him to them. I think that's one we come out on top!
3) If TH does good and WM doesn't, we may have to shop around to see who might be willing to take a chance with WM. We will have to sell him as a RB that has potential but hasn't fully recovered yet. Hopefully, somebody would buy into that.
4) If they both do bad, it's probably not their fault and the OL instead. However, it means that something else is wrong that needs fixing. If we somehow got the opportunity to trade one of them for a 1st rd pick to get a Robert Gallery type of guy that Oakland got, it would be worth it. Sadly, I guy like that doesn't come around often!!!
Mystic
1) Both WM and TH do good
2) WM does good TH does okay (some fumbles)
3) TH goes good, WM doesn't show top form
4) Both WM and TH do bad
The good thing is the Bills like Shaud Williams. Along with Joe Burns, our RB backfield is way too crowded. They may need to get rid of one regardless.
If you had to pick, which one would you pick to go based on the scenarios above?
My opinion:
1) If they both do good, keep TH. He's shown he's a warrior (and is cheap). Of course, WM is younger...it may depend on how good each one was and how close in performance they were...
2) if WM does better, trade TH - perhaps back to Dallas for our pick back. If you think about it, we come out winning on that. Dallas traded their 1st round pick to us and we got Losman to train for a year and add some knowledge and experience to his belt. In turn, we got to keep TH for a year before giving him to them. I think that's one we come out on top!
3) If TH does good and WM doesn't, we may have to shop around to see who might be willing to take a chance with WM. We will have to sell him as a RB that has potential but hasn't fully recovered yet. Hopefully, somebody would buy into that.
4) If they both do bad, it's probably not their fault and the OL instead. However, it means that something else is wrong that needs fixing. If we somehow got the opportunity to trade one of them for a 1st rd pick to get a Robert Gallery type of guy that Oakland got, it would be worth it. Sadly, I guy like that doesn't come around often!!!
Mystic
Comment