If you could have any QB in the NFL...

[Bruce is Loose]

which QB would you rather have on your team?

[lordofgun]

I'd probably pick Vick. Not for this year, but he's going to be even more amazing as his passing gets more accurate and they build a better team around him.

[Novacane]

I'D Take Mcnabb. Brady does not even belong on that list!

[Bruce is Loose]

I definatly have to side with Vick or McNabb - both relativly young QBs with a great arm and monsters on the run... Im going to side with McNabb because hes proved hes a phenom for a few years now and is coming into his prime

[lordofgun]

What's up with Manning. He fell apart last year and hasn't gotten any better. I think he's the type of guy who could benefit from a change of scenery like Drew.

[casdhf]

I'd take Vick too.

[Ebenezer]

the heart says Bledsoe...the brain says McNabb.

[Bruce is Loose]

I put Brady there knowing hed get no votes... I probably should have put Brooks on in his place

[4thAndLong]

Favre.

What about Garcia? How did he not make the list? :gag:

[Novacane]

You should put Feidler on the list too. He'd get 1 vote when WCF shows up.

[Bruce is Loose]

oops - forgot about Garcia... id edit but i dont have permission

[lordofgun]

I added Garcia and Brooks for you. :D

[mybills]

McNabb, without a doubt.

[Dazydog]

I have both Brady and Garcia on my fantasy team. So far they have had similar uneven performances. I think Garcia is the man now though.

:mex:

[BillsOwnAll]

wouldnt mind any of em (cept brady roflmao why is he there?) but i would have to take vick he can run throw and hes young

[BlackJohn]

To complete a team or build around?

If it was to complete a team i'd pick Favre or Bledsoe. Favre been the best for so long. And I don't think anyone could have predicted how well the bills have taken to Bledsoe and vice versa ... like a duck to water!

But to build a team around for the next 10 years either Manning or McNabb. I think Manning's missing his running game, and I think PA passing when you dont have one just hurts you on blitz pickup. He's widely regarded as the hardest working and smartest qb in the league. What's not to like about that?

McNaab looks like the league's new prototype franchise QB. Although I think the pocket passers can make their plays by staying in the pocket longer than a mobile qb. (cunningham was mobile and he managed to get sacked 72 times in a season, and mcnabb collects his share of scks)

I think Vick has to prove his toughness before he'd be my franchise qb ... it looks too easy to knock him out of games although he's soooo fun to watch

[InTheBox]

I would pick bledsoe because i think and the numbers prove it hes the best in this league and he also can motivate the team.

[TigerJ]

I'm not greedy. I'll be satisfied with Bledsoe. Vick is starting to realize his physical potential though. He's pretty amazing.

[WCoastFin]

Id go with MCnabb although it would be a tough decision between him and Favre.

[BADTHINGSMAN]

Definitly, Drew Bledsoe. Vick is having a ton of fun right now. 16 games, 8 left Vicks running around will evetually wear on him. If they make the playoffs Vick will be a tired player.

Between Vick and Mcnabb, go with Mcnabb. Slower but much smarter. Mcnabb realizes he doent need to run every play.

[Marcos20]

McNabb!!!

[shelby]

i love DREEEEEEEEEEEWWWWWW.....
but Vick is simply :angry:ing amazing, and he will only get better.

[Phins054]

For the here and now I'd take Farve...

For the Future I would take Carr...Vick will be a star as well. I am really curious to see what Byron Leftwich can do in the NFL too.

[Mad Bomber]

For the Bills...

Dreeeeeeeewwwwww!

He is a mature QB who has brought the leadership needed by thi Bills in this stage of our rebuilding.

He has done more to define a team identity than any of the other QBs listed on this list could have done for our team.

[BironsGirl43]

Guess who voted for Brady?? *raises hand.. runs* mwahaha.. ;)