My BFZ #3 draft critiques...

[lordofgun]

EE



QB - Solid with McNabb and Leftwich

RB - LT is LT...no debating there. RB #2 becomes an issue which is easily solved if either Dallas back can grab the starting job and the bulk of the carries. Thomas Jones is just a homer pick, but was pretty good value in the 5th round.

WR - Big questions abound - can Chad Johnson be as effective with Carson Palmer throwing the ball? Will Booker and Jimmy Smith rebound?

The rest of the team is solid, although I'll never know why anyone would draft two kickers.

Synopsis: I think this team will finish slightly under .500 as is. No playoffs for you, EE.

[lordofgun]

lordofgun

http://www.billszone.com/fanzone/attachment.php?s=&postid=699946

OK, so I can't be totall objective, but I'll give it a shot:

QB - I actually think Plummer will have a great year. I think QB value can be had very late in most drafts. There's a 70/30 chance this will work out.

RB - Three starters including Priest Holmes and Domanick Davis, and three good sleepers.

WR - Owens and Boldin lead the way. If I can get Winslow in camp, this could be a strong point of my team.

Miami D in round 12 was a crazy steal.

I'm hoping this team challenges for a playoff run! If anyone else wants to critique my team and give a more objective outlook, feel free!

[lordofgun]

Miyagi

http://www.billszone.com/fanzone/attachment.php?s=&postid=699947

QB - A big time question mark. Delhomme is average and Harrington could be boom or bust.

RB - SOLID. Portis, R. Johnson, Charlie Garner, and Travis Minor.

WR - Not as solid. Javon Walker should break out in GB, and Miyagis hoping the same thing for Rogers in Detroit. If all goes well in Red Wing land, the Harrington to Rogers conection could be nice.

I also like the Denver D.

This team should contend for the playoffs.

[lordofgun]

RAMS FAN

http://www.billszone.com/fanzone/attachment.php?s=&postid=699950

Not bad, but not great...average. Several of the picks could have been had later on. Bulger in the second and Bruce in the third were way too early.

Seems like the Rams bias could cost RAMS FAN any shot at postseason play. This team will be a cellar dweller.

[lordofgun]

Sabre Ally

http://www.billszone.com/fanzone/attachment.php?s=&postid=699951

Looks like the team to beat, IMO. The onyl question mark is a #2 RB, but she'll be starting Torry Holt, Hines Ward, and Darrell Jackson as her WR corps to go along with Ahman Green and an underrated Steve McNair. She also picked up the starting RB in Detroit, Rookie Kevin Jones.

If she doesn't walk away with the title, I'll be surprised.

[lordofgun]

I'll be back later with the rest. Time for lunch now...

[lordofgun]

FTG

Good RBs, but you need your WRs to come up big.

Why anyone would draft three QBs is beyond me.

But at least you now have the number one pass weapon in Arizona.

[lordofgun]

R. Rich

Someone must have forgot to tell you how important RBs are in FF. You better hope Manning and Moss can carry you by themselves.

[lordofgun]

chubluv

Your QB and RBs are pretty good, but your WRs are by far the most thin of anyone. Go ahead and drop David Boston.

[lordofgun]

CharlieGuide

You must like old guys. It's no wonder EE likes your team.

Culpepper is great! But Stephen Davis is over 30 now and will be sharing with Foster. And Michael Bennett gets no goalline carries. In case no one noticed, this is a TD-heavy league. I think Moulds will bounce back, but the rest of your WRs are a joke.

[lordofgun]

yle

Congrats on snagging both Raider backs! That's about as good as it gets for you. You need depth. Maybe next time you won't go to Europe in the middle of your fantasy draft.

[lordofgun]

Gunz...

Top-notch depth. Well-rounded team. Can't find much to criticize other than the fact that Fred Taylor doesn't score TDs, and you're going to need your WRs to come through big time.

[lordofgun]

Pat. QBs are good. RBs are good...looks like Quentin Griffin will be a steal in the 6th.

I'm not quite as fond of your WRs, but if K ROB can come through, he and harrison are a nice one-two punch.

You had a couple of huge reaches with Baltimore in Rd. 3 and Eddie Kennison in Rd. 7. Both could have been had several rounds later.

[Earthquake Enyart]

Boy, that was a loooong lunch. :fatkid:

[lordofgun]

Originally posted by Earthquake Enyart
Boy, that was a loooong lunch. :fatkid: