Buffalo Bills Hall of Shame

[OpIv37]

The Rob Johnson thread spurred this idea- who are the worst players/coaches in Bills history and why?

I'll start with the obvious ones-
Rob Johnson- $25 Million for 3 good games and a 2-14 season
Gregg Williams/Kevin Gilbride- I'm sure this needs no further explanation.

Who else?

[Romes]

Chris Watson - Our favorite punt catcher.

[SABURZFAN]

tom cousineau


nuf said

[OpIv37]

Originally posted by Romes
Chris Watson - Our favorite punt catcher.

good choice- his coverage skills were also top-notch

Originally posted by SABURZFAN
tom cousineau


nuf said

Care to elaborate? I think I'm too young to remember this one....

[Crisis]

Originally posted by Romes
Chris Watson - Our favorite punt catcher.

To be fair, before the year he really sucked it up, he was a pretty good special teams player (coverage, not return)...and he was an ok nickel back. Then he nosedived the next season.

[Crisis]

I'd like to add Todd Collins though.

[THATHURMANATOR]

KELSO!!!!

[TheGhostofJimKelly]

The 1980-1985 Buffalo Bills

[Ebenezer]

Originally posted by OpIv37
The Rob Johnson thread spurred this idea- who are the worst players/coaches in Bills history and why?

I'll start with the obvious ones-
Rob Johnson- $25 Million for 3 good games and a 2-14 season
Gregg Williams/Kevin Gilbride- I'm sure this needs no further explanation.

Who else?

Originally posted by OpIv37
good choice- his coverage skills were also top-notch




Care to elaborate? I think I'm too young to remember this one....

I was going to say...this will be interesting based on the age of the poster.


try almost any player on the 1968, 1971 and 1984/5 Bills.

[tomdonahoe]

I never liked Ken Irvin. It may be early but Pucillo may have Hall of Shame written all over him.

[THATHURMANATOR]

Pucillo is well on his way.

[Jan Reimers]

Richie Lucas, first round pick, 1960
Walt Patulski, first round pick, 1972
Al Cowlings, second round pick, 1970(?)
Billy Joe Hobert, useless jerk

To name just a few of my all time "favorites."

[OpIv37]

Originally posted by Jan Reimers

Billy Joe Hobert, useless jerk

I forgot about this guy- taking up way more space on the bench than should ever be allocated to a QB. He was pretty damn useless.

[Ebenezer]

Originally posted by Jan Reimers
Al Cowlings, second round pick, 1970(?)

He was drafted back then because he was OJs buddy.

[OpIv37]

Originally posted by tomdonahoe
I never liked Ken Irvin.

Not as bad as Watson but I do remember him giving up a critical touchdown or two.