Moral Dilemma

[Charlieguide]

OK, here's the deal. I made a trade, and as we're waiting for it to be approved by the commish, the other coach puts a message on the league site saying to enjoy the trade, but that he meant to hit reject, but for some reason hit the accept button.

Here are the details:

-When I offered him the trade, his RB's were S. Alexander, Moe Williams, and LaMont Jordan. I offered him Lamar Gordon and Tiki Barber for Alexander . . . that most likely improves is total output, so I think it's a good move for both of us.

-Sometime after I made the offer (I think) he worked out a deal to trade Gonzalez for Rudi Johnson.

-Both trades are still awaiting final approval.

-The trade forces him to cut a player, and he made that choice as part of the trade (Jordan). The choice to cut is part of the acceptance process, so I don't understand how he could have hit the wrong button . . . Coudn't he have just hit the "back" button?

What would you do:

1) say thank you very much and move on
2) offer to undo it 100%
3) try to find a compromise

[kardshark19]

i'll let you decide what to do, but most people in their right mind would not give Alexander for Lamar Gordon and Tiki

[FTG]

If he had to cut a player for the trade to go through he knew what he was doing. I'd say tough luck and keep the trade.

[lordofgun]

keep it! he obviously just had second thoughts AFTER the fact.

[Mr. Miyagi]

keep it! he obviously just had second thoughts AFTER the fact.

I agree. He couldn't have gone "Oops I meant to reject it" if he had to drop a player to do so. Too bad, so sad.

[Charlieguide]

. . . and then the commish rejected the trade.

[lordofgun]

I'd quit the league. Sure, it's not balanced, but there was no collusion involved.

[Halbert]

Sounds like bs to me.

[BillsFever21]

What deal is it that you don't agree on?


The first two I thought it was set on total votes so it vetoed them. When they did the trade again of Rudi Johnson for Gonzalez I accepted it.

If there is a problem we can have a league vote on it.

[BillsFever21]

Like I said, I didn't know I was gonna be vetoing them. I thought it was set on total votes and my vote would just be added.

Obviously since I rejected with my vote I don't agree on the Alexander for Barber deal but lets hear what everyone else thinks.

We'll have a vote. You need 6 approved votes and we'll accept the trade.

My vote is rejection.

Accept- 0
Reject- 1

[Charlieguide]

This started out as a thread about what I should do myself; I didn't mean to stir things up this much.

One could argue it's not a totally balanced deal, but at the time, it was a deal that would put more points on his scoreboard.