Rookie of the year?

[Bill Brasky]

Who do you think will be rookie of the year based on play up to this point?

I'd give a slight advantage to Roethlisberger over Roy Williams at this point...

[BAM]

Burger... I would throw Sean Taylor up in the mix as well. That guy is a beast.

[RedEyE]

Antonio Gates all the way. He has more WR yards, catches and touchdowns than 7/8 of the WR in the league. Not bad for a TE in San Diego.

[Bill Brasky]

Yeah where the hell did SD come from this year? They should be 4-2... WTF?!

[Ickybaluky]

Gates isn't a rookie, he is in his 3rd season.

I'd go with Roethlisberger at this point, it is too hard for them not to give it to a QB.

[Tatonka]

rothlisberger is a lock for ROY at this point..

4-0 as a rookie qb.. playing with incredible poise and making plays that are way beyond his years.. it really is incredible what he is doing.. it just makes me want to see losman more.

williams had 2 good games..

udeze is having a strong season, as is sean taylor, as far as Defensive ROY..

on a side note.. this draft class of qbs has a good chance to end up being the best since 1983.. all of the qbs have looked good in their limited exposure. i hope they all turn out to be great.

[Mr. Miyagi]

all of the qbs have looked good in their limited exposure. i hope they all turn out to be great.

What? Eli looked horrible in the 2 games he played. No one has seen anything from Rivers or Losman yet.

[Jeff1220]

I'm still hoping Evans turns into a candidate for ROTY over the next several weeks.