who is the bigger bust

[CuseJetsFan83]

A> Ryan Leaf

B> Kellan Winslow II


name some other examples if u think there are worse, *and im sure there are*, than these two

[Philagape]

I don't know if Winslow is a "bust" because his problem has been injuries. Leaf just sucked.

Others:
Tony Mandarich
Aundray Bruce
Akili Smith
All of the expansion Browns' previous first-rounders

[wchutalkinboutwillis]

A> Ryan Leaf

B> Kellan Winslow II


name some other examples if u think there are worse, *and im sure there are*, than these two

Easy....
A) Blair Thomas
B) Anthony Becht

[CuseJetsFan83]

yeah but when winslow actually did play, he wasn't a high impact player, like touted to be.....then again he is with the brownies, which had probably some of the worst offensive statistics for the year.



whats even sadder, is that ive even heard people saying that peyton manning is a bust, because he can't make it to the big game...... in a way i agree, but its not his fault their defense is soft

[CuseJetsFan83]

Easy....
A) Blair Thomas
B) Anthony Becht

blair thomas is very much agreeable.....

becht...... give him a team he can fit in with...... although his hands are about as soft as concrete......... plus he wears that goofy skullcap........


how about a spin...... biggest coaching bust?!?!?

my candidates
A. Rich Kotite
B. Lou Holtz
C. Dennis Erickson
D. Butch Davis

[Philagape]

Steve Spurrier
Gregg Williams


Winslow's entire NFL career is what, two weeks? Too early to judge, I think.

[Slim]

Leaf....altough he did beat the Bills

[Philagape]

Leaf....altough he did beat the Bills

And Rob Johnson "beat" Young's 49ers and Favre's Packers

[LtFinFan66]

You could ask another question too:

Who is the bigger idiot? Leaf or Winslow

[CuseJetsFan83]

You could ask another question too:

Who is the bigger idiot? Leaf or Winslow

hahaha, as nick backay would say : PUSH!

[wchutalkinboutwillis]

You could ask another question too:

Who is the bigger idiot? Leaf or Winslow

Tough call. A lazy number one pick who was once heckled by a fan as having "lunch lady arms" or a young daredevil rebel with fragile knees and a big mouth who's O.M. seems to be to dissappoint his successful Dad. I'd have to take Leaf at this time but it could very well change in the near future.

[losman2evans]

I once spoke to Tony Mandarich back at Michigan State, he was working at Gold's Gym, I remember him saying he would not be another Brian Bosworth.

He turned out worse.

BTW- he seemed to be a real nice guy.

[losman2evans]

oops iI believe it was at Powerhouse gym-not Gold's Gym.

[Morgoth]

Leaf, no contest.

[Jerry Ewert]

Greg williams of the bills