What do you think of my Draft?

[Michael82]

Rochester Rampage 2005 BZFL Rookie Draft

2nd - CB/S Marlin Jackson
2nd - WR Reggie Brown
3rd - OC Chris Spencer
3rd - CB Bryant McFadden
5th - OT Chris Colmer
6th - QB Kyle Orton
6th - CB/KR Darrent Williams
6th - OG Chris Kemoeatu
7th - OLB Nick Speegle
8th - ILB Lance Mitchell

(Keep in mind that I traded my 1st rounder for a 2nd, 3rd in 2005, and a 2nd in 2006. I also received a 30th and 34th round pick in the stocking draft.)

[Canadian'eh!]

solid B+... i like a lot fo those names and many were on my draft list.

only lost the A because you never had a 1st.

[Michael82]

solid B+... i like a lot fo those names and many were on my draft list.

only lost the A because you never had a 1st.
yeah, but that hurt me a bit, but look at what i got for the 1st...2 solid stocking draft picks (TE Jeb Putzier and G Jake Scott), a 2nd and 3rd rounder for this draft, and a 2nd rounder next year too. :up:

[Canadian'eh!]

yeah, but that hurt me a bit, but look at what i got for the 1st...2 solid stocking draft picks (TE Jeb Putzier and G Jake Scott), a 2nd and 3rd rounder for this draft, and a 2nd rounder next year too. :up:
my grade is not based on the deal or needs.... just the players. good deal though.

[Michael82]

my grade is not based on the deal or needs.... just the players. good deal though.
Yeah, it's too hard to grade based on the trade. You are right though. Without the 1st rounder, it's hard to give an A. Thanks for the feedback though. :up:

[Michael82]

Any more comments? :feedback:

[R. Rich]

Rochester Rampage 2005 BZFL Rookie Draft

2nd - CB/S Marlin Jackson
2nd - WR Reggie Brown
3rd - OC Chris Spencer
3rd - CB Bryant McFadden
5th - OT Chris Colmer
6th - QB Kyle Orton
6th - CB/KR Darrent Williams
6th - OG Chris Kemoeatu
7th - OLB Nick Speegle
8th - ILB Lance Mitchell

(Keep in mind that I traded my 1st rounder for a 2nd, 3rd in 2005, and a 2nd in 2006. I also received a 30th and 34th round pick in the stocking draft.)


Jackson: B (a bit overrated, but I do like how physical he is)
Brown: C (decent when he shows up to play, Fred Gibson was better)
Spencer: A (best center available and versatile enough to play guard too)
McFadden: B (great cover corner!)
Colmer: C (nasty attitude, but not a good athlete; illness/injury concerns)
Orton: B (good value here, but must be more consistent)
Williams: B (sold value, excellent cover skills)
Kemoeatu: B (could be a steal here, if he controls his temper; a beast!)
Speegle: C (another Mike Mamula???)
Mitchell: C (could go up he's past the injuries, love his tenacity)
Draft Moves/Picks Acquired: C (couldn't get a 1st to move down?)

Overall: B-/C+

[SABURZFAN]

i gave it a B+.you would have gotten an A had you picked up a RB with one of your last two picks.


jmo....

[Michael82]

i gave it a B+.you would have gotten an A had you picked up a RB with one of your last two picks.


jmo....
Yeah, I was thinking about an RB, but there was no good ones available. They were all taken early.

[Michael82]

Jackson: B (a bit overrated, but I do like how physical he is)
Brown: C (decent when he shows up to play, Fred Gibson was better)
Spencer: A (best center available and versatile enough to play guard too)
McFadden: B (great cover corner!)
Colmer: C (nasty attitude, but not a good athlete; illness/injury concerns)
Orton: B (good value here, but must be more consistent)
Williams: B (sold value, excellent cover skills)
Kemoeatu: B (could be a steal here, if he controls his temper; a beast!)
Speegle: C (another Mike Mamula???)
Mitchell: C (could go up he's past the injuries, love his tenacity)
Draft Moves/Picks Acquired: C (couldn't get a 1st to move down?)

Overall: B-/C+
Thanks for the comments Rich. I really like Reggie Brown. I was looking for a receiver that I feel is going to make an impact on an NFL team this year. He will probably be the 3rd receiver and depending on TO, may even be a 2nd.

I really like Colmer, but his injury history bothers me a bit...but it was in the 5th round...so if he doesn't do much, oh well. At least I got a tackle for depth.

[Devin]

For not having a 1st rounder you recovered well, like the CB picks.