Most overrated NFL player of all time?

[Bill Brasky]

I don't know who I'd say is the most overrated, but I would have to put Joe Namath near the top of that list.

The guy didn't even surpass 30,000 career yards, threw more INT's than TD's, and had maybe 2 "good" seasons his entire career.

If not the most overrated, def. the most overrated hall of famer to ever play football.

Who do you think is the most overrated player in NFL history?

Most overrated in Bills history?

[DynaPaul]

Re: Most overrated NFL player of all time?

Randall Cunningham

[DynaPaul]

Re: Most overrated NFL player of all time?

And Hershell Walker.

Can't forget about him...

[DBam]

Re: Most overrated NFL player of all time?

"The Boz"

Tony Manderich

[Jan Reimers]

Re: Most overrated NFL player of all time?

Paul Hornung.

[Mike13]

Re: Most overrated NFL player of all time?

Until he becomes a better passer Vick is overrated.

[FlyingDutchman]

Re: Most overrated NFL player of all time?

Keyshawn Johnson...hes a dip s***

[Night Train]

Re: Most overrated NFL player of all time?

I don't know who I'd say is the most overrated, but I would have to put Joe Namath near the top of that list.

The guy didn't even surpass 30,000 career yards, threw more INT's than TD's, and had maybe 2 "good" seasons his entire career.

If not the most overrated, def. the most overrated hall of famer to ever play football.

Who do you think is the most overrated player in NFL history?

Most overrated in Bills history?

Just curious, how old are you ? Did you ever see Namath play in person ? I probably saw him live about 6 times, starting in the 60's.

He was fantastic. I never saw anyone who could just flick the ball 60 yards and hit either Don Maynard or George Sellers in stride. Dan Marino copied his arm motion to the letter.

Bob Griese is in the HOF. That's the worst selection in the history of Canton.

Most overrated Bill. Cornelius Bennett. Talley was twice the player.

[Captain gameboy]

Re: Most overrated NFL player of all time?

Just curious, how old are you ? Did you ever see Namath play in person ? I probably saw him live about 6 times, starting in the 60's.

He was fantastic. I never saw anyone who could just flick the ball 60 yards and hit either Don Maynard or George Sellers in stride. Dan Marino copied his arm motion to the letter.

Bob Griese is in the HOF. That's the worst selection in the history of Canton.

Most overrated Bill. Cornelius Bennett. Talley was twice the player.

Fully agree.

Not just on Namath, but on Bennett.

Namath was one of the few divisional rivals that earned the respect of Bills fans.

I'd say Junior Seau.

[Ebenezer]

Re: Most overrated NFL player of all time?

Emmitt Smith - Average running back behind the best OL ever.
Michael Vick - Please. RBs should not be under center.
Dan Marino - Great arm. Terrible leader, selfish player, never was a team so about one person.

Most overrated Bill: Even though he was an 8 time probowler and had a chance at the HOF at one time: Ruben Brown.

[chernobylwraiths]

Re: Most overrated NFL player of all time?

I don't know about one player, but I know about one play that is the most overrated in NFL history, "the catch". I mean Dwight Clark basically jumped about a foot and a half and caught the ball and people think it was some marvel of human engineering.

[Mudflap1]

Re: Most overrated NFL player of all time?

Some overrated players:

Roman Gabriel
Wahoo McDaniel
Sam Huff (good, but not great)
Warren Moon (good, but not great)
Hollywood Henderson
Duane Thomas
Fred Williamson
Andre Rison
Chuck Muncie
Conrad Dobler

Most overrated Bill:

Ruben Brown
John Fina
Jay Reimersma

Most underrated Bill:

Andre Reed

Jon

[pleasesavedrew]

Re: Most overrated NFL player of all time?

I don't know who I'd say is the most overrated, but I would have to put Joe Namath near the top of that list.

The guy didn't even surpass 30,000 career yards, threw more INT's than TD's, and had maybe 2 "good" seasons his entire career.

If not the most overrated, def. the most overrated hall of famer to ever play football.

Who do you think is the most overrated player in NFL history?

Most overrated in Bills history?

Broadway Joe is an NFL legend and was a great player, especially considering how bad his knees were. There would be no AFL, which means no Buffalo Bills, if Joe wouldn't have signed with the Jets. All fans of original AFL teams should be grateful of Joe. By the way, most quarterbacks of Joe's time threw more INTs than TDs. Such as Jack Kemp and many others.

[casdhf]

Re: Most overrated NFL player of all time?

Terry Bradshaw

[pleasesavedrew]

Re: Most overrated NFL player of all time?

Ruben Brown is definetly overated. i don't feel Steve tasker got as much credit as he deserves. Same with ralph Wilson.