Kelly Holcomb 24/31 308 9.9 1 1

[sba]

Losman should have to beat him out next year.

[RedEyE]

Re: Kelly Holcomb 24/31 308 9.9 1 1

Sure. They're both under contract, take it into training camp.

[Devin]

Re: Kelly Holcomb 24/31 308 9.9 1 1

Yup. Losman is my boy, but next season he has to earn his job.

[Das_Bills]

Re: Kelly Holcomb 24/31 308 9.9 1 1

Even though Iam a JP man I wanted to say even though alot of people hate it Holcomb had a great game. I just wish we would have won the games that really mattered

[Novacane]

Re: Kelly Holcomb 24/31 308 9.9 1 1

Cleveland fans thought they had thier savior after the Pittsburg playoff games. KH will have games like this now and then and fool a lot of fans into thinking he can be a winning full time starter . He's a very good backup. Period

[STAMPY]

Re: Kelly Holcomb 24/31 308 9.9 1 1

A fight in camp is only right. Let the best man win the job. I think JP will win it out. But make him earn it.

[RedEyE]

Re: Kelly Holcomb 24/31 308 9.9 1 1

Problem is still the OL. Either QB plays better behind a good OL.

[RedEyE]

Re: Kelly Holcomb 24/31 308 9.9 1 1

This competition will only make JP a better player.

[fabolouspaul]

Re: Kelly Holcomb 24/31 308 9.9 1 1

I'm just glad both of them are on our team.

[Michael82]

Re: Kelly Holcomb 24/31 308 9.9 1 1

A fight in camp is only right. Let the best man win the job. I think JP will win it out. But make him earn it.

Good post.

[RedEyE]

Re: Kelly Holcomb 24/31 308 9.9 1 1

I think part of the problem early in the season was JP came into the season as the starter. Not the best way to handle an unproven rookie.

Competition for a starting slot always brings the best out of a player.

[Michael82]

Re: Kelly Holcomb 24/31 308 9.9 1 1

I think part of the problem early in the season was JP came into the season as the starter. Not the best way to handle an unproven rookie.

Competition for a starting slot always brings the best out of a player.

Thats exactly what I was thinking. I was shocked that he was handed the job. And I think the vets hated that too. Holcomb had the better camp and the better season. He should be offered a chance to compete for the job next year.

[RedEyE]

Re: Kelly Holcomb 24/31 308 9.9 1 1

Thats exactly what I was thinking. I was shocked that he was handed the job. And I think the vets hated that too. Holcomb had the better camp and the better season. He should be offered a chance to compete for the job next year.

I think he should as well. Still, I think JP will prove he is the better QB.

[X-Era]

Re: Kelly Holcomb 24/31 308 9.9 1 1

Losman should have to beat him out next year.

Outstanding idea, lets start a QB controversy, that way should win us at least one more game, set Losman back farther, and with any luck we can sh_t can the 07 season too.

Good call!

Hell if you can score 6 points a half against good teams, you should be able to go at least 6 and 10.

Holcomb is nothing more than a career backup. The only downside on Losman is that he wasnt Roth who could overcome a horrendous o-line and march us to the playoffs. Holcomb AINT a playoff or SB caliper QB, game over, discussion over, and decision over.

[Philagape]

Re: Kelly Holcomb 24/31 308 9.9 1 1

If JP is still struggling next summer, then go with Holcomb.