If Davis & Cutler make Young slide, Does Buffalo take him?

[patmoran2006]

What would you do? Its VERY hypothetical right now (so damn much can change once FA starts and teams plug in needs that route)

But for discussion sake, lets just say the top seven end this way:
1- Houston- Bush
2- N.O- Leinart
3- Tenn- Young
4- Jets- Brick
5- GB- Mario Williams
6- SF- Hawk
7- Oak- Vernon Davis or Huff

8- Buffalo.. Do you take Vince Young?

[ICE74129]

F#@k NO!

[patmoran2006]

What would you do? Its VERY hypothetical right now (so damn much can change once FA starts and teams plug in needs that route)

But for discussion sake, lets just say the top seven end this way:
1- Houston- Bush
2- N.O- Leinart
3- Tenn- Young
4- Jets- Brick
5- GB- Mario Williams
6- SF- Hawk
7- Oak- Vernon Davis or Huff

8- Buffalo.. Do you take Vince Young?

OOPS.. I mean CUTLER goes three to Tenn.. Not Young

[Devin]

id cry.

If it went like that id want whoever Oakland doesnt draft or Ngata.

[T-Long]

I know this is just for discussion, but there is no WAY he makes it past the Raiders

[YardRat]

If Young actually did score a six on the wonderlic, I'd be erasing him completely off my board.

[clumping platelets]

NO!!!

[patmoran2006]

Quote from Jim Rome today in his "email bag"..

"So I heard that Vince Young scored a six on his Wonderlic test. God damn.. that boy is a genius!"
Signed-
Dexter Manley

[patmoran2006]

Mike Tyson wasn't exactly the brighest cookie in the Jar, but he knew how to box.. catch my drift.. (and I dont think Young only scored a 6 btw).

put it this way.. If I posed this SAME question a week after the rose bowl, I think the answers would have been very different.. He can do things at QB, at least from I seen personally that nobody in the NFL, not even Vick can do.

[camelcowboy]

Mike Tyson wasn't exactly the brighest cookie in the Jar, but he knew how to box.. catch my drift.. (and I dont think Young only scored a 6 btw).

put it this way.. If I posed this SAME question a week after the rose bowl, I think the answers would have been very different.. He can do things at QB, at least from I seen personally that nobody in the NFL, not even Vick can do.

QB is a position that i wouldn't take a chance with someone with a stub standard intelligence. Running back is one thing, but a qb is suppose to be a general. A stupid general who likes to run. Not a good combination "ask the french"

All this assumes that the Wonder lick is a good test. Which i don't really think it is. Build the lines. We busted on TD, for making the sexy flashy pick. I don't want a QB, or WR, or A tightend who can outrun everyone, give me a line, with out a line all these sexy picks won't be worth a damn.

[Drive 4 Five]

I don't see the point of drafting another unproven QB prospect when we don't even know what we have in Losman. NFL Network reported earlier that New Orleans coach Sean Payton is absolutely "intrigued" with Cutler. A possible trade early on? Not Buffalo but another team perhaps?

[THE END OF ALL DAYS]

A stupid general who likes to run. Not a good combination "ask the french"


Now thats efin funny!

[Bmax]

Jets rumored to be moving up to draft leinart.... If that happens then

1.Jets-Leinart
2.NO-Cutler-payton likes him
3.Tenn-Young-Mcnair tutors him for two years..
4.Houston-Bush
5.GB-MARIO WILLIAMS-could trade with tenn to get bush...They also like Lendale White
6.San Fran-AJ Hawk
7. Oakland-Davis
8. BUFFALO -BRICK

LONG SHOT BUT COULD HAPPEN

[vicmantak]

Totally and absolutely not.

On the other hand, you are right. Tennessee will draft Jay Cutler if they are commited in a QB.

[Tatonka]

i honestly would lose all faith in the bills before the season even started if young was the pick.

[casdhf]

Vince Young will make Andre Ware's career look outstanding.

[TigerJ]

I probably would not draft him anyway, but I don't think I'd even consider a QB who scored under a 15 on the Wonderlic, and he would have to give me a really compelling reason to consider him if he scored less than 20.

[justasportsfan]

NO qb's. I would take Marcus Vick if he goes undrafted :D. I doubt Shanahan let's him go though if he's there in the 3rd rd.

[Gunzlingr]

If the bills drafted any qb in the first round this year, I would start looking for a new team, because they are absolutely hopeless.

[The Spaz]

If we take a QB it better be Cutler.

[Saratoga Slim]

NO!!!

Dammit patmoran, you made Clump yell. No more talk of drafting a QB.

[Spiderweb]

What would you do? Its VERY hypothetical right now (so damn much can change once FA starts and teams plug in needs that route)

But for discussion sake, lets just say the top seven end this way:
1- Houston- Bush
2- N.O- Leinart
3- Tenn- Young
4- Jets- Brick
5- GB- Mario Williams
6- SF- Hawk
7- Oak- Vernon Davis or Huff

8- Buffalo.. Do you take Vince Young?

Heck NO !!!!!

[djjimkelly]

not much would make me question my being a bills fan but the taking of vince young would kill 90% of my love for the team. that being said this is not a move that will happen. hopefully it shapes up like this and some team wants to give the world for the 8th pick!

[RedEyE]

There are some desperate teams in the top 5 that need a QB. I don't see him making out of the top 10. Personally I wouldn't take the guy, but it may be hard for some GMs and coaches to pass him up.

[PromoTheRobot]

Mike Tyson wasn't exactly the brighest cookie in the Jar, but he knew how to box.. catch my drift.. (and I dont think Young only scored a 6 btw).

put it this way.. If I posed this SAME question a week after the rose bowl, I think the answers would have been very different.. He can do things at QB, at least from I seen personally that nobody in the NFL, not even Vick can do.
Here's a bulletin: College football is NOT the NFL!!!!

I think you and your fellow Young devotees are enthralled of what he did at Texas, but forgetting that 99% of the defenders he faced will NOT be playng football after graduation. Run-n-gunners like Young rarely succeed in the NFL because the defenses they face are just too good. Unless Young has excelent passing skills (which he doesn't) and the ability to read defenses in snap (based on his Wonderlic, that's doubtful) then his chances of success in the NFL are slim at best.

But hey, don't let the facts spoil your boner for the guy. And by the way, Young DID score a 6 on his first test, then a 16 on atest given to him again, after some "coaching."

PTR

[Bert102176]

it would be stupid very stupid to draft a QB, we have Losman and Holcomb and can bring in someone in FA for the 3rd spot