Miami fans officially biggest homers

[thejetfan]

http://www.finheaven.com/boardvb2/sh...d.php?t=137144

http://www.finheaven.com/boardvb2/sh...d.php?t=137143

They're trying to say that Ronnie Brown is a top 10 RB after he had one average season and that Brown is currently a better NFL RB then the Cadillac. They also think that Chambers is a better WR then Joe Horn and Issac Bruce even though Chambers had one good season and has shown no sign of being consistent, yet. Idiots... I guess if Jerricho Cotchery of the New York Jets has 60 catches at 8 TDs next year he's automatically a top 10 WR? They need to get a clue...

[Devin]

Re: Miami fans officially biggest homers

Wow lol.

I wont argue that Brown isnt a great back or even that he has miles of potential.....but top 10? After 1 season? Caddy only played 14 games, had he played all 16 hed have likely broken 1300-1400 yards.

Regardless, Brown is a great player but top 10 in todays NFL....not hardly.

[Bling]

Re: Miami fans officially biggest homers

Better than Caddy? That's a matter of opinion. I think he is, and the only person outside of Tommy Tuberville that has the best opinion is Nick Saban. I trust that opinion.


Top 10? Not yet.

[Bling]

Re: Miami fans officially biggest homers

But honestly, why are you posting that over here?

[Devin]

Re: Miami fans officially biggest homers

Better than Caddy? That's a matter of opinion. I think he is, and the only person outside of Tommy Tuberville that has the best opinion is Nick Saban. I trust that opinion.


Top 10? Not yet.

Probably one of the few posts youve made i agree with.

Both backs posses qualities the other doesnt. I can truly see them being pretty balanced in coming years as far as production.

[feelthepain]

Re: Miami fans officially biggest homers

Wow lol.

I wont argue that Brown isnt a great back or even that he has miles of potential.....but top 10? After 1 season? Caddy only played 14 games, had he played all 16 hed have likely broken 1300-1400 yards.

Regardless, Brown is a great player but top 10 in todays NFL....not hardly.

Ronnie didn't play a full season either and finished just shy of 1000 yrds rushing. Ricky finished the year strong he ran for 300 yrds the last two games combined and finished with 743 yrds with a 4.4 avg. ypc and 6 TD's between the two thats nearly 1800 yrds and 10 TD's, I'm not trying to make excuses because I don't have to, but compare that to Caddy's 1178 yrds and 4.1 ypc and Caddy had nearly 100 more touches then Brown, those numbers favor Brown.

Caddy also didn't split the carries with anyone and he didn't go into a system that was in it's first year. I think Caddy is a very good RB, but not better then Ronnie and obviously neither does Nick. Nick coached against both backs many times, he's seen more film on the two of them then anybody and he had the chance to choose either. According to Nick he chose the back that had more to offer in his opinion. I'd say that's a pretty knowledgeable opinion.

As for homers, every team site has their share. I could find a few ridiculous posts here, finheaven or at Jets nation that are like the ones posted above. Big deal, there just opinions it's not life or death and I'll bet most that post that way are in their teens and probably given the choice would rather spend a Sunday at the mall then watching a football game.

[clumping platelets]

Re: Miami fans officially biggest homers

Miami fans homers??? Please say it ain't so

[Bill Brasky]

Re: Miami fans officially biggest homers

Joe Horn is a top 5 WR... Chambers is good, but he's not even a top 10 WR IMO.

[Slim]

Re: Miami fans officially biggest homers

Joe Horn is a top 5 WR... Chambers is good, but he's not even a top 10 WR IMO.

Chambers is not top 10.... Im pretty sure half of the yards he had last season was agianst us though.

[Devin]

Re: Miami fans officially biggest homers

Chambers is a solid WR, a great #2 WR.

He had'nt had a 1K season yet in his career, and had he not had 238 yards against us he would have had yet another mediocre season as a #1 with 880 yards.

That being said the Fins havent had a QB since Marino and their other WR's have basically sucked major ASS.

[Bill Brasky]

Re: Miami fans officially biggest homers

I don't see why we're bashing the Fins fans here...

They have talent in Brown and Chambers, it's justifiable for them to be excited.

The Bills have "unproven talent" in a lot of different positions.

Last year, they had "unproven talent" in Losman and a lot of people here thought we were going to the playoffs and winning 11-12 games.

[Bling]

Re: Miami fans officially biggest homers

Joe Horn is a top 5 WR... Chambers is good, but he's not even a top 10 WR IMO.

No.

1. Randy Moss
2. Terrell Owens
3. Torry Holt
4. Chad Johnson
5. Steve Smith


You're telling me you'd take Horn over them? top 10, yes.

[Bling]

Re: Miami fans officially biggest homers

Chambers is a solid WR, a great #2 WR.

He had'nt had a 1K season yet in his career, and had he not had 238 yards against us he would have had yet another mediocre season as a #1 with 880 yards.

That being said the Fins havent had a QB since Marino and their other WR's have basically sucked major ASS.

A great #2 implies that he's worse than 32 #1 WR's. You can't tell me 15 WR's better than him. He's a solid #1.

[Devin]

Re: Miami fans officially biggest homers

No.

1. Randy Moss
2. Terrell Owens
3. Torry Holt
4. Chad Johnson
5. Steve Smith


You're telling me you'd take Horn over them? top 10, yes.

Gotta agree again. Although Id throw either of the AZ duo (Boldin/Fitz in instead of Holt)

[Devin]

Re: Miami fans officially biggest homers

A great #2 implies that he's worse than 32 #1 WR's. You can't tell me 15 WR's better than him. He's a solid #1.

To some degree your right. Ill give you that, I dont know if id agree that hes a solid #1, but like E-Mo to some degree hes a victim of circumstance to poor players at QB/WR.