If the season were to end today the Bills would be around the 9th pick area of the NFL draft. With teams like Cleveland, St. Louis, Oakland, and Seattle ahead of them, it will be hard to get a Bradford or Clausen-type QB. I believe that Marshawn is perfect trade bait and we could easily send him to a team like Cleveland or Seattle in order to get a higher pick.
No thanks. I'd rather trade our first rounder for a late first rounder to grab another first rounder next year or move up in next year's draft. I don't mind trading Marshawn either. If we could get a 3rd rounder in this year's draft for him, I'm all for it.
That is total nonsense!!!
A 3rd rounder for a guy with this much upside?
Thank god you guys have day jobs, instead of running a football team.
RBs are a dime a dozen. Lynch is going to run for less than 500 yards this year at around 3.8 ypc. His biggest year was 1100 yards. He's been in trouble with the law multiple times. And he's been outplayed and passed on the depth chart by an undrafted free agent. Running backs don't tend to get better with age - so where's all this upside you speak of?Originally Posted by nateodoms'bff
Running backs are a dime a dozen. I highly doubt we could get a 3rd for Lynch with all his off field problems.
Holy Crap I posted almost the exact same thing!
Lynch is worth a 2nd round pick from a contender, thus a mid to late 2nd round pick is acceptable value for him, anything less won't cut it. Good luck trying to find a better running back than Marshawn Lynch past the 1st round.
Teams to consider:
Houston Texans
San Diego Chargers
Washington Redskins
Cleveland Browns
Kansas City Chiefs
Detroit Lions
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Marshawn Lynch instantly makes all these teams better, if we can't get a 2nd for him then fine, I'd hold onto him. I'll take Jackson and Lynch as my runningback combo for the foreseeable future.
Last edited by PECKERWOOD; 12-30-2009 at 01:06 PM.
We're hoping to get Cowher here and people want to trade Marshawn? :banghead:
Marshawn would be lucky to get a 4th from someone.
Especially with how he's performed this year and his off the field trouble.
To be honest, I dunno if we could even trade our 1st plus Marshawn to move up about 5 spots in the draft.
I am with you.
I do like him but Lets be serious.
The one thing Lynch has going for him is his carries have been limited this year. I like Lynch a lot and see a big need for him on this team. Jackson is just as valuable but he's a side to side runner and has shone a lot this year because we dont' have the run blocking for a punishing runner like Lynch. To have these two guys on the team is a huge asset and trading one away would be taking a step backwards IMO unless it was going to bring in a top tier QB.
I generally like Lynch too, and he would obviously be more effective with a decent o-line. I just think people tend to overstate his value here. He's a tough solid runner, but there are a lot of guys like that in the NFL.
Now if Lynch had any vision and could actually hit the hole quickly, he'd be an elite guy.
Well there are just no QBs projected to go in the first that are worth trading Lynch to aquire. Besides, we will pretty much have our pick of the litter where we are picking anyways. And if we chose a QB in RD1 or 2, I will probably break something and get into trouble.
see this is my point. why trade away a top tier running back, when you canhave him on your team.
his problems with the law are over and done with. marshawn is a smart kid. he learned his lesson, and I can guarantee there will be no more incidents with him again. he has great hands, great vision, and power. he may not have break away speed, but he doesnt need it when he is mowing defenders down. playing in this offense, any running back would be "trade bait", and thats the problem. As fans we want so much, yet we rarely see the talent we have. The only real offensive weapons that this team has are Lynch and Jackson. I dont count Lee Evans because as we have seen before, he disappears for games at a time, and cant catch a ball over the middle of the field (like a true #1 can).
Trading Lynch is a mistake. Really trading any player from this team that has any value is foolish. There arent enough weapons as it is, so trading them for mid round draft picks makes the least amount of sense.
And for the record, RB's are not a dime a dozen. Elite guys go in the first round. The ham and eggers, and grinders go later. Thank god we have both on this team.
Too bad the ham and egger we have we drafted in the first round and the guy closer to elite wasn't even drafted.
You can get a good RB in any round of the draft or even undrafted
Michael Turner 5th round pick
MJD 2nd round pick
Ray Rice 2nd round pick
Ryan Grant undrafted
Brandon Jacobs 4th round
Now, would you say Lynch is even in any of these guys class?
With that answer who trades for a dime a dozen RB when you can get a guy who's better in a later round?
Cleveland no longer needs a RB
the only guys better on that list are MJD and Turner. I would rather have Lynch over Rice, Grant and Jacobs any game.
Rice and Lynch are on par with one another. Grant has speed, but I dont care for his lack of power. He is more Roger Craig than Steven Jackson. Brandon Jacobs is a big goof who is afraid to make contact now that he is rich. I watch the Giants every week, and he has brought the offense to its knees this season.
Those are so few far and in between, that's like saying that we should hold off on drafting a tackle until the 2nd day of the draft because we signed Jason Peters as an UDFA and because we drafted Howard Ballard in the 11th round.
Btw, I'd take Marshawn Lynch over Brandon Jacobs from that list, but granted, Michael Turner and MJD are elite talent. Although I think Grant is a product of the system and I think Lynch could do the same thing in GB.
Last edited by PECKERWOOD; 12-30-2009 at 09:47 PM.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
