Page 1 of 4 1234 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 63

Thread: Should Religions be insulted with impunity?

  1. #1
    Registered User MidnightVoice's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2003
    Location
    In the sixties
    Posts
    9,467
    Thanks
    42
    Thanked 1,672 Times in 998 Posts
    Power to Give Rep
    30
    ZoneBux
    11,414.47
    Bank
    738,565.01
    Total ZoneBux
    749,979.48
    Donate

    Should Religions be insulted with impunity?

    Salman Rushdie and John le Carré have been fighting for years, and have just "made up". The fight had its roots in Le Carré's criticism of The Satanic Verses: "My position was that there is no law in life or nature that says great religions may be insulted with impunity," said Le Carré.

    But is there any natural law that says they cannot be insulted? Why has the UN condemned "defamation of religion." ?

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defamat...United_Nations

    What is so special about religion that we cannot condemn it for its idiocies?
    What can be asserted without proof can be dismissed without proof ~ Christopher Hitchens

  2. Post thanked by:

    gebobs (11-12-2012),ICRockets (11-12-2012)

  3. #2
    One Bills Drive, Georgia - 871 miles south of Orchard Park gebobs's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2003
    Location
    Atlanta
    Posts
    6,204
    Thanks
    3,546
    Thanked 3,107 Times in 1,980 Posts
    Power to Give Rep
    25
    ZoneBux
    51,026.16
    Bank
    120,203.85
    Total ZoneBux
    171,230.01
    Donate

    Re: Should Religions be insulted with impunity?

    Quote Originally Posted by MidnightVoice View Post
    Why has the UN condemned "defamation of religion." ?
    There is a subtle shift in the UN resolution now that it protects believers, not beliefs. To be clear, the resolution is toothless.
    Gailey's history. He just doesn't know it yet.

  4. #3
    Registered User MST3KBillsfan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2006
    Posts
    6,416
    Thanks
    7,141
    Thanked 1,884 Times in 1,335 Posts
    Power to Give Rep
    22
    ZoneBux
    98,736.65
    Bank
    0.00
    Total ZoneBux
    98,736.65
    Donate

    Re: Should Religions be insulted with impunity?

    Can we make fun of athiests?

  5. #4
    Registered User jimmifli's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Posts
    3,010
    Thanks
    3,475
    Thanked 2,681 Times in 1,263 Posts
    Power to Give Rep
    15
    ZoneBux
    40,082.59
    Bank
    0.00
    Total ZoneBux
    40,082.59
    Donate

    Re: Should Religions be insulted with impunity?

    Quote Originally Posted by Gibby View Post
    Can we make fun of athiests?
    Ahhh, the persecuted majority.

  6. Post thanked by:

    gebobs (11-12-2012)

  7. #5
    Hey man, wanna breed? Spartacus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2003
    Posts
    13,814
    Thanks
    2,579
    Thanked 4,044 Times in 2,560 Posts
    Power to Give Rep
    40
    ZoneBux
    154,876.22
    Bank
    0.00
    Total ZoneBux
    154,876.22
    Donate

    Re: Should Religions be insulted with impunity?

    Quote Originally Posted by MidnightVoice View Post
    Salman Rushdie and John le Carré have been fighting for years, and have just "made up". The fight had its roots in Le Carré's criticism of The Satanic Verses: "My position was that there is no law in life or nature that says great religions may be insulted with impunity," said Le Carré.

    But is there any natural law that says they cannot be insulted? Why has the UN condemned "defamation of religion." ?

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defamat...United_Nations

    What is so special about religion that we cannot condemn it for its idiocies?
    I wasn't aware of this spat so I can't say for sure, but it reads to me like Le Carre was talking about the incident in realpolitick terms. In other words, if you kick someone with the ability and will to kick back, no matter how much they deserve it, you can't be surprised if they hit back.

    Notice how he used the word "insulted" which isn't the same thing as condemn.
    boisterous hubris, arrogance, self deception, conspiracy, mud slinging mixed with a heavy dose of self righteousness.

  8. #6
    One Bills Drive, Georgia - 871 miles south of Orchard Park gebobs's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2003
    Location
    Atlanta
    Posts
    6,204
    Thanks
    3,546
    Thanked 3,107 Times in 1,980 Posts
    Power to Give Rep
    25
    ZoneBux
    51,026.16
    Bank
    120,203.85
    Total ZoneBux
    171,230.01
    Donate

    Re: Should Religions be insulted with impunity?

    Quote Originally Posted by Gibby View Post
    Can we make fun of athiests?
    If you promise to try and spell it right, I have no problem. But it better be original. Theists have been taking potshots at us for years. They are typically unimaginative or downright stupid: "no atheists in foxholes", the Pascal wager, "atheism is a faith", "Hitler was an atheist", etc. etc.

  9. Post thanked by:

    jimmifli (11-12-2012)

  10. #7
    Registered User jimmifli's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Posts
    3,010
    Thanks
    3,475
    Thanked 2,681 Times in 1,263 Posts
    Power to Give Rep
    15
    ZoneBux
    40,082.59
    Bank
    0.00
    Total ZoneBux
    40,082.59
    Donate

    Re: Should Religions be insulted with impunity?

    Quote Originally Posted by gebobs View Post
    If you promise to try and spell it right, I have no problem. But it better be original. Theists have been taking potshots at us for years. They are typically unimaginative or downright stupid: "no atheists in foxholes", the Pascal wager, "atheism is a faith", "Hitler was an atheist", etc. etc.
    "So Hitler and Pascal walk into a foxhole..."

  11. Post thanked by:

    gebobs (11-12-2012),JATMtheJATM (11-12-2012),Spartacus (11-12-2012),Tagir (11-12-2012)

  12. #8
    Registered User MidnightVoice's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2003
    Location
    In the sixties
    Posts
    9,467
    Thanks
    42
    Thanked 1,672 Times in 998 Posts
    Power to Give Rep
    30
    ZoneBux
    11,414.47
    Bank
    738,565.01
    Total ZoneBux
    749,979.48
    Donate

    Re: Should Religions be insulted with impunity?

    Quote Originally Posted by Spartacus View Post
    I wasn't aware of this spat so I can't say for sure, but it reads to me like Le Carre was talking about the incident in realpolitick terms. In other words, if you kick someone with the ability and will to kick back, no matter how much they deserve it, you can't be surprised if they hit back.

    Notice how he used the word "insulted" which isn't the same thing as condemn.
    Insulting Islam was what Rushdie was condemned to death for by the Mullahs. My question is, why is religion so special that it cannot be insulted? Why do blasphemy laws exist? And should they? Why should someone be condemned for insulting something as transient as a religion?

  13. #9
    One Bills Drive, Georgia - 871 miles south of Orchard Park gebobs's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2003
    Location
    Atlanta
    Posts
    6,204
    Thanks
    3,546
    Thanked 3,107 Times in 1,980 Posts
    Power to Give Rep
    25
    ZoneBux
    51,026.16
    Bank
    120,203.85
    Total ZoneBux
    171,230.01
    Donate

    Re: Should Religions be insulted with impunity?

    Quote Originally Posted by MidnightVoice View Post
    Insulting Islam was what Rushdie was condemned to death for by the Mullahs. My question is, why is religion so special that it cannot be insulted? Why do blasphemy laws exist? And should they? Why should someone be condemned for insulting something as transient as a religion?
    No ideas should be above criticism.

  14. Post thanked by:

    imbondz (11-13-2012)

  15. #10
    CIA-MIC profiteer extraordinaire Muktar al-Portlandi's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2012
    Location
    Portland, Oregon Cocoa Mate: al-Sharti
    Posts
    1,622
    Thanks
    648
    Thanked 448 Times in 304 Posts
    Power to Give Rep
    5
    ZoneBux
    44,996.78
    Bank
    0.00
    Total ZoneBux
    44,996.78
    Donate

    Re: Should Religions be insulted with impunity?

    Quote Originally Posted by Gibby View Post
    Can we make fun of athiests?
    Only while we're alight.

  16. #11
    Registered User MidnightVoice's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2003
    Location
    In the sixties
    Posts
    9,467
    Thanks
    42
    Thanked 1,672 Times in 998 Posts
    Power to Give Rep
    30
    ZoneBux
    11,414.47
    Bank
    738,565.01
    Total ZoneBux
    749,979.48
    Donate

    Re: Should Religions be insulted with impunity?

    Quote Originally Posted by gebobs View Post
    No ideas should be above criticism.
    Agreed. But people make laws about insulting religions

  17. #12
    Hey man, wanna breed? Spartacus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2003
    Posts
    13,814
    Thanks
    2,579
    Thanked 4,044 Times in 2,560 Posts
    Power to Give Rep
    40
    ZoneBux
    154,876.22
    Bank
    0.00
    Total ZoneBux
    154,876.22
    Donate

    Re: Should Religions be insulted with impunity?

    Quote Originally Posted by MidnightVoice View Post
    Insulting Islam was what Rushdie was condemned to death for by the Mullahs. My question is, why is religion so special that it cannot be insulted? Why do blasphemy laws exist? And should they? Why should someone be condemned for insulting something as transient as a religion?
    Religion CAN be insulted.

    And mullahs CAN issue fatwas.

  18. #13
    Hey man, wanna breed? Spartacus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2003
    Posts
    13,814
    Thanks
    2,579
    Thanked 4,044 Times in 2,560 Posts
    Power to Give Rep
    40
    ZoneBux
    154,876.22
    Bank
    0.00
    Total ZoneBux
    154,876.22
    Donate

    Re: Should Religions be insulted with impunity?

    Quote Originally Posted by MidnightVoice View Post
    Agreed. But people make laws about insulting religions
    No one expects the Spanish Inquisition!

  19. #14
    It's soooo embarrassing YardRat's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Location
    A hole in your wall.
    Posts
    41,826
    Thanks
    4,224
    Thanked 3,914 Times in 2,206 Posts
    Power to Give Rep
    127
    ZoneBux
    171,316.22
    Bank
    0.00
    Total ZoneBux
    171,316.22
    Donate

    Re: Should Religions be insulted with impunity?

    If it's any consolation MV, apparently churches aren't eligible for any FEMA assistance.

    Long you live and high you fly And smiles you'll give and tears you'll cry And all you touch and all you see Is all your life will ever be.

  20. #15
    One Bills Drive, Georgia - 871 miles south of Orchard Park gebobs's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2003
    Location
    Atlanta
    Posts
    6,204
    Thanks
    3,546
    Thanked 3,107 Times in 1,980 Posts
    Power to Give Rep
    25
    ZoneBux
    51,026.16
    Bank
    120,203.85
    Total ZoneBux
    171,230.01
    Donate

    Re: Should Religions be insulted with impunity?

    Quote Originally Posted by MidnightVoice View Post
    Agreed. But people make laws about insulting religions
    Not in democracies.

  21. #16
    One Bills Drive, Georgia - 871 miles south of Orchard Park gebobs's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2003
    Location
    Atlanta
    Posts
    6,204
    Thanks
    3,546
    Thanked 3,107 Times in 1,980 Posts
    Power to Give Rep
    25
    ZoneBux
    51,026.16
    Bank
    120,203.85
    Total ZoneBux
    171,230.01
    Donate

    Re: Should Religions be insulted with impunity?

    Quote Originally Posted by Spartacus View Post
    Religion CAN be insulted.

    And mullahs CAN issue fatwas.
    But not so good when the fatwas call for violence.

  22. #17
    Go Sabres!! Gilly's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2012
    Location
    Tucson, AZ
    Posts
    967
    Thanks
    401
    Thanked 212 Times in 150 Posts
    Power to Give Rep
    4
    ZoneBux
    12,133.03
    Bank
    65,946.45
    Total ZoneBux
    78,079.48
    Donate

    Re: Should Religions be insulted with impunity?

    I think that religious jokes are on par with race of gay jokes. They are tasteless but there shouldn't be a law against them...
    If you like your health care plan, you will be able to keep your health care plan. Period. No one will take it away. No matter what.
    President Obama July/ 2009,

    ...

  23. #18
    Registered User ICRockets's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Posts
    1,645
    Thanks
    646
    Thanked 925 Times in 523 Posts
    Power to Give Rep
    10
    ZoneBux
    22,114.89
    Bank
    0.00
    Total ZoneBux
    22,114.89
    Donate

    Re: Should Religions be insulted with impunity?

    Quote Originally Posted by Gilly View Post
    I think that religious jokes are on par with race of gay jokes. They are tasteless but there shouldn't be a law against them...
    How are they on par? You CHOOSE to be whatever religion you are. If that religion says you get your own planet when you die then you'd better believe I'm giving you **** for that.

  24. Post thanked by:

    gebobs (11-13-2012)

  25. #19
    Negavite Sammich OpIv37's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2002
    Location
    Baltimore, MD
    Posts
    73,870
    Thanks
    3,352
    Thanked 6,240 Times in 3,108 Posts
    Power to Give Rep
    208
    ZoneBux
    165,782.70
    Bank
    497,546.56
    Total ZoneBux
    663,329.26
    Donate

    Re: Should Religions be insulted with impunity?

    Quote Originally Posted by MidnightVoice View Post
    Insulting Islam was what Rushdie was condemned to death for by the Mullahs. My question is, why is religion so special that it cannot be insulted? Why do blasphemy laws exist? And should they? Why should someone be condemned for insulting something as transient as a religion?
    here's the problem: believers in their religion truly believe that their religion is the word of God. It is holy, sacred, and infallible, so if you insult it, you are insulting God himself. That's why blasphemy laws exist.

    The reality, though, is that religion is an instrument of control. Believers are obedient, and the people who control the religion (or the governments in the case of Muslim theocracy) benefit greatly from obedience. So, anything that casts even an iota of doubt on their religion or makes the devout even stop to think about their beliefs for a minute becomes a threat to those in power. The attempt to limit insults or even legitimate debate/criticism simply shows the weakness of their position and the way they are attempting to use religion as a control mechanism.

  26. #20
    i appear missing JoeMama's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2002
    Posts
    6,164
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 5,382 Times in 2,495 Posts
    Power to Give Rep
    27
    ZoneBux
    78,917.05
    Bank
    0.00
    Total ZoneBux
    78,917.05
    Donate

    Re: Should Religions be insulted with impunity?

    Quote Originally Posted by Spartacus View Post
    Religion CAN be insulted.

    And mullahs CAN issue fatwas.
    You mean it's not a conspiracy?

    Some Muslims are in fact lunatics like every other major religion???

    This is a major breakthrough for you!

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •