Thoughts on the trade with KC?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • kgun12
    Registered User
    • Jul 2002
    • 11317

    #46
    Re: Thoughts on the trade with KC?

    Originally posted by TacklingDummy View Post
    I don't care about point value. Only way you win the trade is if the players you select with those picks work out. If you are drafting someone like John McCargo I wouldn't consider that a win.

    If Mahoomes becomes a franchise QB you lost, big time.
    That's a big if, by ALL accounts from the "experts" there wasn't a starting QB in this draft. Mahoomes has a big arm, so what.
    Retired Air Traffic Controller
    USAF VETERAN
    DAV

    Comment

    • Bill Cody
      Registered User
      • Sep 2004
      • 11887

      #47
      Re: Thoughts on the trade with KC?

      Conceptually I like the move. The history of the draft says more picks = better results in the long run, particularly for a team like the Bills that needs to add talent. But obviously it comes down to what we do with the picks. I had my eye on Marshon Lattimore and he was available so that's the obvious comparison right out of the blocks. If Lattimore turns out to be an all pro and White is JAG then we had better absolutely nail the other two picks. If those guys turn out to be similar players we'll probably win the deal from that standpoint. The other guy that we'll need to keep an eye on is the guy KC traded up to get, Mahomes. I liked him but I though he was more of a 2nd round guy but obviously his performance post season has shot his stock way up. If he turns out to be a franchise signal caller KC won't regret what they paid for a minute and we'll wish we had taken him ourselves.

      But I said before the draft my first choice was a trade down so tough for me to dump on the move, especially since we appear to have not taken a bust which is nice and refreshing. If we grab a steal with that 3rd rounder I think everyone will fell a little better about this no matter what your thoughts are now. So let's wait and see.

      Comment

      • TacklingDummy
        Unreachable Douche
        • Jul 2002
        • 71725

        #48
        Re: Thoughts on the trade with KC?

        Originally posted by kgun12 View Post
        That's a big if, by ALL accounts from the "experts" there wasn't a starting QB in this draft. Mahoomes has a big arm, so what.
        I don't want any QB in this draft.

        All I'm saying is the point value thing is stupid. Trading down is stupid. Losers trade down.

        Comment

        • Historian
          2020-2023 AFC East Champions!
          • Dec 2002
          • 61715

          #49
          Re: Thoughts on the trade with KC?

          Originally posted by TacklingDummy View Post

          Trading down is stupid. Losers trade down.
          New England does it every year.

          Comment

          • feldspar
            Registered User
            • Mar 2007
            • 13620

            #50
            Re: Thoughts on the trade with KC?

            Originally posted by TacklingDummy View Post
            Losers trade down.
            New England has traded down and stockpiled picks WAY more than any other team I can think of offhand. Belichick is famous for that, among other things. What he's not famous for is losing...
            Last edited by feldspar; 04-28-2017, 09:58 AM.

            Comment

            • LarryBoy
              The world needs a hero!
              • Apr 2003
              • 881

              #51
              Re: Thoughts on the trade with KC?

              I get tired of hearing "Andy Reid" is smarter then we are...yea maybe however many "smarter" people wanted Ryan Leaf...

              In the end its all a crapshoot...
              Bills Rock!





              Comment

              • Joe Fo Sho
                Making Spirits Bright
                • Mar 2006
                • 6194

                #52
                Re: Thoughts on the trade with KC?

                Originally posted by TacklingDummy View Post
                I don't want any QB in this draft.

                All I'm saying is the point value thing is stupid. Trading down is stupid. Losers trade down.
                Trading down is not necessarily stupid. If losers trade down, then do winners trade up? Did we win the Watkins trade? Or the Losman Trade?

                Looking at each trade objectively without making blanket statements is probably the right thing to do.

                Comment

                • psubills62
                  Legendary Zoner
                  • Sep 2008
                  • 11295

                  #53
                  Re: Thoughts on the trade with KC?

                  It doesn't quite sit right with me. I get that the point values work out, but still feels like - based on other trades and the value that was sitting there - we could have gotten more for it. I also didn't want to trade that far down, so we could still get a good prospect like Malik Hooker (he's been my guy, but using as an example for now).
                  "Misguided political correctness tethers our intellects."
                  - Nicholas Cummings

                  Comment

                  • Joe Fo Sho
                    Making Spirits Bright
                    • Mar 2006
                    • 6194

                    #54
                    Re: Thoughts on the trade with KC?

                    Originally posted by feldspar View Post
                    New England has traded down and stockpiled picks WAY more than any other team I can think of offhand. Belichick is famous for that, among other things. What he's not famous for is losing...
                    Recently, Cleveland has done the best job of acquiring draft picks. They've yet to see any improvement from it, though. I'm rooting for them, it's the biggest and most drastic rebuild I've ever seen. Time will tell.

                    Comment

                    • Bill Cody
                      Registered User
                      • Sep 2004
                      • 11887

                      #55
                      Re: Thoughts on the trade with KC?

                      Originally posted by TacklingDummy View Post
                      Trading down is stupid. Losers trade down.
                      well then San Francisco must be a bunch of idiots. They moved down 1 slot, took the player they were targeting anyway and picked up a 3rd and a 4th this year and a 3rd next year. How dumb is that?

                      Comment

                      • kgun12
                        Registered User
                        • Jul 2002
                        • 11317

                        #56
                        Re: Thoughts on the trade with KC?

                        Originally posted by TacklingDummy View Post
                        I don't want any QB in this draft.

                        All I'm saying is the point value thing is stupid. Trading down is stupid. Losers trade down.
                        I agree on the QB but not the trade down comment. Everyone on this site who hates everything about what the Bills do ALWAYS talk about the greatness of the Pats and they have built the greatest franchise ever moving down and accumulating picks.
                        Retired Air Traffic Controller
                        USAF VETERAN
                        DAV

                        Comment

                        • kgun12
                          Registered User
                          • Jul 2002
                          • 11317

                          #57
                          Re: Thoughts on the trade with KC?

                          Cleveland did a great job of moving down and stock piling pick and on paper with their stock pile have had a fantastic draft! Even if the don't have another pick so far they are winning!
                          Retired Air Traffic Controller
                          USAF VETERAN
                          DAV

                          Comment

                          • TacklingDummy
                            Unreachable Douche
                            • Jul 2002
                            • 71725

                            #58
                            Re: Thoughts on the trade with KC?

                            Originally posted by Historian View Post
                            New England does it every year.
                            Actually NE trades up in the 1st round more than it trades down.

                            2001: Stayed and drafted Richard Seymour
                            2002: Traded up with Washington and drafted Daniel Graham
                            2003: Some how got Balt. pick, ahead of their own, drafted Vince Wolfork
                            2004: Traded up with Washington and drafted Ty Warren
                            2005: Stayd put, Logn Mankins
                            2006: stayed put, Lawrence Maroney
                            2007: Traded up with Seattle, drafted Brandon Merriweather, other pick Traded to SF who took Joe Staley
                            2008: Traded up with NO and drafted Jerod Mayo, other pick Forfieted for Spygate
                            2009: Traded back twice, Baltimore selected Michael Oher, GB selected Clay Matthews
                            2010: Not sure what went on here, all I know the trades turned into Denver D. Thomas, Dallas Dez Bryant, NE Devon McCourty and Rob Gronkowski
                            2011: Traded Richard Seymour for Oaklands 1st, traded their own first for NO 2nd and 1st
                            2012: Traded up twice, once with Cincy (Chandler Jones) and with Denver (Donte Hightower)
                            2013: Traded back
                            2014: stayed
                            2015: stayed
                            2016: Forfited
                            2017: Traded for Cooks

                            Whatever NE does turns to gold for all involved. I hate (jealous) them.

                            Comment

                            • Jry44
                              Registered User
                              • Apr 2013
                              • 607

                              #59
                              Re: Thoughts on the trade with KC?

                              Originally posted by Historian View Post
                              New England does it every year.
                              So does Seattle.

                              If winning Super Bowls makes us a loser, than I'm all in!

                              Comment

                              • TacklingDummy
                                Unreachable Douche
                                • Jul 2002
                                • 71725

                                #60
                                Re: Thoughts on the trade with KC?

                                Originally posted by Bill Cody View Post
                                well then San Francisco must be a bunch of idiots. They moved down 1 slot, took the player they were targeting anyway and picked up a 3rd and a 4th this year and a 3rd next year. How dumb is that?
                                Well that's because the Bears are just as dysfunctional as the Bills.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X