QB Watch Thread

[DraftBoy]

Watched every throw of Darnold v. ND.

He looked pretty average for most of the night. Consistently missed receivers but then would make a pinpoint throw seemingly out of blue. His confidence is shot right now.

[Mace]

Give me Rudolph over all of them. Darnold and Rosen both need to stay in school.

Well, refine that, in terms of how you feel about him, atm ? I'm not seeing enough college ball for perspective.

Do you mean you'd spend lots of picks getting to Rudolph, or take him if available in normal order ?

[DraftBoy]

Well, refine that, in terms of how you feel about him, atm ? I'm not seeing enough college ball for perspective.

Do you mean you'd spend lots of picks getting to Rudolph, or take him if available in normal order ?

I would entertain a trade up for Rudolph, yes.

[swiper]

While TDs and INTs were the same, it looks like Mayfield > Rudolph yesterday.

[swiper]

So. After yesterday's games what is the list of top 5 QBs on our wish list, in order please?

Based largely on QB ratings, I offer this list:

Mayfield
Rudolph
Darnold
Rosen
Falk

Agree? Disagree? Is that list close?

Are those 5 all first rounders in 2017 (given Darnold declares)?

[DraftBoy]

So. After yesterday's games what is the list of top 5 QBs on our wish list, in order please?

Based largely on QB ratings, I offer this list:

Mayfield
Rudolph
Darnold
Rosen
Falk

Agree? Disagree? Is that list close?

Are those 5 all first rounders in 2017 (given Darnold declares)?

I'd go:

Rudolph
Darnold
Mayfield
Rosen
Finley

Mayfield is going to be a divisive prospect because he's under sized has an average to above average arm but clearly has the "IT" factor. The question with Mayfield is can you deal with his need to improvise and can he learn a traditional offense? I don't think labeling Mayfield as a Russell Wilson type prospect is accurate because he's not as risk averse as Wilson was in college. Mayfield has no problem taking a shot down the field or throwing into tighter windows. It's also not fair to give him a Manziel type of label that others have brought forth because he does like to improvise and plays in a non-traditional offense (Oklahoma runs an Air Raid system). He's a tough read, but I think I'd take a shot on him mid-late in Round 1 if he makes it that far. He's not a guy I would up into the Top 10 to try and take though.

[Mouldsie]

Rosen tops my list, the others are still sorting themselves out.