It’s narrow-minded to say Bills haven’t succeeded without a Super Bowl

[Woodman]

Bills head coach Sean McDermott knows that a Super Bowl is the ultimate goal, and his team has fallen short in each of his seven seasons at the helm. But don’t tell him Buffalo hasn’t had success.

McDermott told Tom Pelissero of NFL Network that the Super Bowl isn’t the only measure of a coach’s accomplishments, of quarterback Josh Allen’s accomplishments, or of the team’s accomplishments.

“I think like anything, when you talk about the Bills, whether it’s Josh, myself, our team, we’ve had so much success,” McDermott said. “What’s left for Josh and for all of us is to take that one more step that we need to take. To say we haven’t had success or Josh hasn’t had success, I think would be kind of narrow-minded. It’s hard to win in the NFL, so you kind of regroup every year, and you take it one game at a time. But we’re all looking for Josh to really be that face of the franchise, like he’s been, and continuing to evolve, like he’s always done.”

[Forward_Lateral]

Re: It’s narrow-minded to say Bills haven’t succeeded without a Super Bowl

Oh this is going to bring all the crybaby haters to the yard

[jamze132]

Re: It’s narrow-minded to say Bills haven’t succeeded without a Super Bowl

I’d rather watch the Bills win 10-12 reg season games and make the playoffs, winning the division every year, even without a Super Bowl, rather than ever live thru the drought again.

We also have hope right now where before we were simply hoping to win more than we lost.

[OpIv37]

Re: It’s narrow-minded to say Bills haven’t succeeded without a Super Bowl

Loser talk. If Josh Allen is your QB and you can’t win even one title, it’s a failure.

[OpIv37]

Re: It’s narrow-minded to say Bills haven’t succeeded without a Super Bowl

I’d rather watch the Bills win 10-12 reg season games and make the playoffs, winning the division every year, even without a Super Bowl, rather than ever live thru the drought again.

We also have hope right now where before we were simply hoping to win more than we lost.

Yeah, it’s better than that, but it’s an extremely low bar. The Patriots won 6 during our drought. Mahomes already has 3. 1 in 58 SB’s shouldn’t be too much to ask.

[OpIv37]

Re: It’s narrow-minded to say Bills haven’t succeeded without a Super Bowl

We already have one of the greatest QB’s to never win a title in Jim Kelly.

Those early 90’s teams had 6 HOF’ers plus a HOF coach and GM. They shattered all kinds of records, including one that will prob never be broken in the number of consecutive conf titles.


History is repeating itself. We have another team getting wins and putting up monster numbers but failing to win the big prize.

[Canadian'eh!]

Re: It’s narrow-minded to say Bills haven’t succeeded without a Super Bowl

Loser talk. If Josh Allen is your QB and you can’t win even one title, it’s a failure.

Are things much better than the 20 years of fail? Absolutely.

But do I want a Head Coach whose attitude is “we did pretty good”? Absolutely not. There’s levels to success. We aren’t a laughingstock anymore, and if that’s your goal…. Mission accomplished.

But the only true goal of the NFL is to win a Super Bowl. The Great QBs win them. Josh Allen is great. The bar has been elevated. McD trying to lower it to save his ass is not a good look.

whether be liked It or not, the bar is now Super Bowl or it’s a failed season. And a HC who needs to claim playoff appearances are good enough is a HUGE problem.

[Canadian'eh!]

Re: It’s narrow-minded to say Bills haven’t succeeded without a Super Bowl

I’d rather watch the Bills win 10-12 reg season games and make the playoffs, winning the division every year, even without a Super Bowl, rather than ever live thru the drought again.

We also have hope right now where before we were simply hoping to win more than we lost.

It doesn’t have to be one or the other. The goal is Super Bowl. The HC is trying to lower that bar, which is very telling

[YardRat]

Re: It’s narrow-minded to say Bills haven’t succeeded without a Super Bowl

The disappointment of not being able to get over the hump is greater than trying to get to that level, the higher expectations make the fall that much farther.

Taking a trash heap and making them respectable isn't that difficult for somebody that is competent...or shouldn't be.
Staying there for an extended period of time is somewhat of an accomplishment, so kudos for that.
But when 'competent' becomes consistently the end result, one has to start looking at why they haven't been able to improve on that and figure out how to fix it.

Because ultimately the goal is supposed to be winning championships, not stacking regular season wins and breaking records.

[Forward_Lateral]

Re: It’s narrow-minded to say Bills haven’t succeeded without a Super Bowl

I’d rather watch the Bills win 10-12 reg season games and make the playoffs, winning the division every year, even without a Super Bowl, rather than ever live thru the drought again.

We also have hope right now where before we were simply hoping to win more than we lost.

This.

The excitement every Sunday brings me now compared to the misery it brought me for most of my life as a Bills fan is worth it alone. Do I want to see them win a Superbowl? As much as anyone on the planet.

Will I lose sleep over it if they don't? Nope. Sundays from Sept to Jan are my escape. Watching football is what I enjoy. Watching the Bills pretty much win every time they play compared to like 35% of the time is much more enjoyable and satisfying.

I do not ever want to re-live 20+ years of mediocre to terrible football teams.

[Canadian'eh!]

Re: It’s narrow-minded to say Bills haven’t succeeded without a Super Bowl

This.

The excitement every Sunday brings me now compared to the misery it brought me for most of my life as a Bills fan is worth it alone. Do I want to see them win a Superbowl? As much as anyone on the planet.

Will I lose sleep over it if they don't? Nope. Sundays from Sept to Jan are my escape. Watching football is what I enjoy. Watching the Bills pretty much win every time they play compared to like 35% of the time is much more enjoyable and satisfying.

I do not ever want to re-live 20+ years of mediocre to terrible football teams.

Is it more fun to watch now? Yes.
Will I stop watching if they never win a SB? No.

But the goal today is the same as it was every year they sucked. WIN THE SUPER BOWL. Being closer is not the attitude they should have.

McD is wrong. They are 'more successful" but in the NFL the only true success is measured in trophies.

[Bill Cody]

Re: It’s narrow-minded to say Bills haven’t succeeded without a Super Bowl

we kinda need 1

[mightysimi]

Re: It’s narrow-minded to say Bills haven’t succeeded without a Super Bowl

It really just boils down to how you view success. Compared to many teams, the Bills have been very successful. Compared to the Chiefs and Patriots they have not.

Like has been said though, I will take this over the drought any day. Watching the Panthers overpay guys just to get them to go there used to be us. The offseason and draft used to be our superbowl. Now there is a chance at the real one almost every year. I will take it.

[Forward_Lateral]

Re: It’s narrow-minded to say Bills haven’t succeeded without a Super Bowl

Is it more fun to watch now? Yes.
Will I stop watching if they never win a SB? No.

But the goal today is the same as it was every year they sucked. WIN THE SUPER BOWL. Being closer is not the attitude they should have.

McD is wrong. They are 'more successful" but in the NFL the only true success is measured in trophies.

The goal when they sucked was not a superbowl.

Anyone who says or thinks that is delusional.

[jamze132]

Re: It’s narrow-minded to say Bills haven’t succeeded without a Super Bowl

It doesn’t have to be one or the other. The goal is Super Bowl. The HC is trying to lower that bar, which is very telling

He’s not lowering the bar, he’s simply acknowledging where we’re at and how far we’ve come. If you don’t think he and every person at OBD is doing everything in their power to win a SB, you’re crazy. Only one team gets to win every year and it takes more than just talent and coaching to do so. It takes a LOT of luck too with injuries, scheduling, weather, other teams failures, etc. I know that sounds like a bunch of crappy excuses but it’s true. One team is able to rise above it all each year and 31 other teams fail.