Bledsoe is not today’s QB

[Throne Logic]

Originally posted by TedMock
Mark Campbell said that we didn't have one play action in the entire playbook last season.

It's the numerous tidbits like this one that everyone should focus on.

The coaching problems form the past two years are not someone's opinion. They are documented fact. Recorded statistics, such as nearly 80 straight pass attempts on 3rd and short, should not be overlooked.

Drew does have problems. Always has had them. Everyone in the league is aware of them. Drew also has a couple of assets that everyone in the league is aware of two. That's what happens when you've been around for 10 years. You aren't going to shock anyone with new abilities. Unfortunately, GW and Gilbride never seemed to have read that scouting report. Or any scouting report, for that matter.

As I've stated before, I absolutely refuse to judge the performance of any of last year's Offensive players because all of those performances were tainted by the coaching.

Case in point: Drew had nearly 50 sacks last season. How many do you think resulted from those nearly 80 straight 3rd and short pass attempts? Now, how many do you think resulted from the complete lack of a play action arrangement? That's just the two factors we've mentioned in this thread. Mr. Imobile might cut his sack total in half this year with very little change on his part. If Sam can teach Drew to let it go a bit sooner, that number might drop by 2/3.

[Philagape]

All signs point to a Drew comeback. He's proven that he can play very well, with help. Help has arrived.

[Hemlepp53]

Drew Bledsoe.. I wont lie fellas I went out and Bought myself a Drew Jersey... =P But last season was not impressive... Leaving 2002 season I was hopefull.. hell I was VERY Hopefull. I thought we were Playoff Bound... Again... I think its possible this season as well.. But thats a different Thread... I want Drew play like a BIG MONEY QB should play. He has all the tools at his disposal to to have a Career Season, but will he. Time will tell. I place faith in the new coaching staff and the new WARRIORS we have added to our TEAM. The question is what was the problem Drew had last year was it the Lack of Receivers, The Lack of Protection, The Playbook, The Coaching Staff, or DREW... I can tell you whatever the problem was it was surely addressed this off season. We got receivers!!! We Got Help On The Protection Issues, We got a NEW playbook, We got new Coaching Staff, And hell fellas we got a decent guy riding Shotgun (JP). So lets all stop reading things we feel like we've 1500 times and focus on what is to come not what has left. Just my thoughts... I'm sure I RANTED on and on.. But hey guys "GET USED TO IT..." =P

[Jan Reimers]

If this team shapes up as most of us expect - better coaching, O line, running attack and receivers - but Drew still struggles, I think most of us who have supported him will say honestly that his time is up.

[Charlieguide]

Originally posted by TedMock
Mark Campbell said that we didn't have one play action in the entire playbook last season. . .

:hamrhed:

WHAT?!?!?!?! How can you have a TOP TIER running back in Travis Henry, getting near (exceeding, in some cases) 5ypc, and not have a SINGLE play action in the book?! I can't get over how brilliant Gilbride's passing theory can be, when his overall gameplan is so WACKED!

(why does this even surprise me?)

As for Drew, let's not forget that this is the same guy that nearly broke Marino's single-season passing record in 2002. Yeah, I think you've got to at least be kinda good to do that.

[Mr. Cynical]

Originally posted by Charlieguide
As for Drew, let's not forget that this is the same guy that nearly broke Marino's single-season passing record in 2002. Yeah, I think you've got to at least be kinda good to do that.

Marino's record: 5084 Yards, 48 TDs / 17 INTs
Drew's '02 stats: 4359 Yards, 24 TDs / 15 INTs

[Jan Reimers]

I'm amazed that Eli, Big Ben and Rivers were all taken so early when clearly - according to this moronic article at least - they suffer from many of the same shortcomings which plague Drew.

If you believe the author, we got the best of the top 4 QBs in Losman.

[Charlieguide]

Originally posted by Mr. Cynical
Marino's record: 5084 Yards, 48 TDs / 17 INTs
Drew's '02 stats: 4359 Yards, 24 TDs / 15 INTs

And that's not impressive?

Recall that through most of the season, he was on/ahead of Marino's pace; it was the last few games that production slipped. Thank you Kevin Gilbride for 'sticking with the gameplan that has worked so far.'

[Dozerdog]

Who wrote that stuff anyway???

[Mr. Cynical]

Originally posted by Charlieguide
And that's not impressive?

Recall that through most of the season, he was on/ahead of Marino's pace; it was the last few games that production slipped. Thank you Kevin Gilbride for 'sticking with the gameplan that has worked so far.'

I didn't say it wasn't impressive. I was just showing that it wasn't quite as close as the word "nearly" implies.

The difference between them is 725 yards. Since Drew's average was 272 YPG, he would have needed almost 3 more games to close that gap. And the fact that Marino threw exactly twice as many TDs (48 vs. 24) with only 2 more INTs is not very close at all.

Now, I completely agree KG was an idiot and that certainly didn't help him. But the greats seem to somehow make things work out (for the most part...nobody is perfect). Drew had some very good numbers that year (at least for half the season) but that's pretty much been the trend of his career - inconsistency.

And one more point on another of his career trends. His record that year against teams .500 and over was 3-8 (2 wins over Mia; 1 over SD) and 5-0 vs. teams with losing records (where most of his good stats came from). Yes this is a team game but it is still worth noting IMO.

[buffmaniac]

Originally posted by Mr. Cynical
And one more point on another of his career trends. His record that year against teams .500 and over was 3-8 (2 wins over Mia; 1 over SD) and 5-0 vs. teams with losing records (where most of his good stats came from). Yes this is a team game but it is still worth noting IMO.

But that is like that for any QB. Look at Brady. Now last year they only lost 2 games the whole year so you have to get them credit. But look at his first 2 years:

2001
9-0 vs. teams with losing record
2-3 vs. teams .500 or better

2002
3-0 vs. teams with losing record
6-7 vs. teams .500 or better

[Mr. Cynical]

Originally posted by buffmaniac
But that is like that for any QB. Look at Brady. Now last year they only lost 2 games the whole year so you have to get them credit. But look at his first 2 years:

2001
9-0 vs. teams with losing record
2-3 vs. teams .500 or better

2002
3-0 vs. teams with losing record
6-7 vs. teams .500 or better

I don't have the stat handy but Drew's career W-L against teams over 500 is really bad, especially for someone at his salary. Also it is important to remember that this is over an 11 year span, not just a couple of years.

Not sure why you continue comparing to Brady. Is it because of BB getting rid of Drew and keeping Brady? Fair enough. Thing is, I think it's more relevant to compare him to other QBs who have been making the same kind of money Drew has, e.g., Favre, Manning, McNair, etc. If you compare his W-L against winning teams against those QBs you'll see a much bigger gap.

P.S. Even looking at those years for Brady - he is almost 500 against winning teams, which is still far better than Drew*.

* Before anyone says it, yes I know it is a team game.

Edit: I'm done with the Reality of Drew for awhile. I'm even getting on my own nerves now. I'll give it a rest for....say, a week.