Top 10 QBs in the NFL

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Sportsuser101
    Registered User
    • Feb 2005
    • 2705

    Top 10 QBs in the NFL

    1 Peyton Manning
    2 Tom Brady
    3 Daunte Culpepper
    4 Matt Hasslebeck
    5 Donovan McNabb
    6 Drew Brees
    7 Brett Favre
    8 Steve McNair
    9 Marc Bulger
    10 Michael Vick

    Comments?
    Dareus - 1st Round Pick
  • Yasgur's Farm
    Moderator
    • Feb 2005
    • 7091

    #2
    Nice list... I dunno about Michael Vick as a top 10 though. His passer rating and other stats weren't much better (if at all) than the Drewler. To me, he's more of a gimmick player who will attain a bit more success than did Kordell Stewart.

    Here's to seeing JP on that list in the near future.

    Comment

    • Sportsuser101
      Registered User
      • Feb 2005
      • 2705

      #3
      Originally posted by draz54
      Nice list... I dunno about Michael Vick as a top 10 though. His passer rating and other stats weren't much better (if at all) than the Drewler. To me, he's more of a gimmick player who will attain a bit more success that did Kordell Stewart.

      Here's to seeing JP on that list in the near future.
      I was torn on whether to put him on the list or not but I felt his overall impact on the game at the QB position was huge.
      Dareus - 1st Round Pick

      Comment

      • Crisis
        Registered User
        • Aug 2004
        • 12738

        #4
        Brady #1
        Manning #2

        Hassleback would be nothing if he didn't run a WCO.

        Bulger throws way too many INTs to be top 10.
        Originally posted by LOSman WINS
        Vanek is Austrian not European
        Originally posted by Prov401
        Pacquiao isn't asian. He's from the philippines
        Originally posted by better days
        I will not be surprised if Tebow has more success than Peyton in the NFL.

        Comment

        • Sportsuser101
          Registered User
          • Feb 2005
          • 2705

          #5
          Originally posted by Crisis
          Brady #1
          Manning #2

          Hassleback would be nothing if he didn't run a WCO.

          Bulger throws way too many INTs to be top 10.
          Who would you put in there ahead of them?
          Dareus - 1st Round Pick

          Comment

          • gr8slayer
            Registered User
            • Feb 2005
            • 20796

            #6
            How on Earth can you have Matt Hasslebeck in your top five? The guy sucks.

            Comment

            • Crisis
              Registered User
              • Aug 2004
              • 12738

              #7
              Leftwich, Delhomme
              Originally posted by LOSman WINS
              Vanek is Austrian not European
              Originally posted by Prov401
              Pacquiao isn't asian. He's from the philippines
              Originally posted by better days
              I will not be surprised if Tebow has more success than Peyton in the NFL.

              Comment

              • Italian Stallion
                Knows More Than You
                • Feb 2004
                • 1136

                #8
                Originally posted by Crisis
                Bulger throws way too many INTs to be top 10.
                I agree with that statement, and the fact that Brees is a one year wonder at this point....heres my list

                1. Tom Brady
                2. Peyton Manning
                3. Daunte Cullpepper
                4. Brett Farve
                5. Donovan McNabb
                6. Trent Green
                7. Chad Pennington
                8. Michael Vick (in terms of worth to team and winning games not stats)
                9. Jake Delhomme
                10. Byron Leftwich
                BILLS FOOTBALL

                SABRES HOCKEY

                METS BASEBALL

                I like cheeseburgers and eva mendes

                Comment

                • Crisis
                  Registered User
                  • Aug 2004
                  • 12738

                  #9
                  Green is behind probably the best OL in the game, has the best running game in the league, and the best TE in the league. He's top 15 for sure, no way top 10.
                  Originally posted by LOSman WINS
                  Vanek is Austrian not European
                  Originally posted by Prov401
                  Pacquiao isn't asian. He's from the philippines
                  Originally posted by better days
                  I will not be surprised if Tebow has more success than Peyton in the NFL.

                  Comment

                  • Sportsuser101
                    Registered User
                    • Feb 2005
                    • 2705

                    #10
                    Originally posted by gr8slayer
                    How on Earth can you have Matt Hasslebeck in your top five? The guy sucks.
                    If his WRs would catch the ball he would have alot better #s.
                    Dareus - 1st Round Pick

                    Comment

                    • Italian Stallion
                      Knows More Than You
                      • Feb 2004
                      • 1136

                      #11
                      Originally posted by Sportsuser101
                      If his WRs would catch the ball he would have alot better #s.
                      I was just gonna post the same thing....Jackson and Robinson suck
                      BILLS FOOTBALL

                      SABRES HOCKEY

                      METS BASEBALL

                      I like cheeseburgers and eva mendes

                      Comment

                      • RetroRaiders81
                        Raidaas Fans Watch Will and Grace
                        • Mar 2005
                        • 2196

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Sportsuser101
                        Who would you put in there ahead of them?
                        I'm guessing his 3 superbowl rings, but thats b/c he plays on a very complete team. Imagine Peyton with a defense like the Pats. I'm thinking undefeated.
                        The Houston Retro Raiders.

                        Comment

                        • Crisis
                          Registered User
                          • Aug 2004
                          • 12738

                          #13
                          Brady wins games! How many SBs has he won on 2 minute drills? Peyton chokes in the playoffs.
                          Originally posted by LOSman WINS
                          Vanek is Austrian not European
                          Originally posted by Prov401
                          Pacquiao isn't asian. He's from the philippines
                          Originally posted by better days
                          I will not be surprised if Tebow has more success than Peyton in the NFL.

                          Comment

                          • RetroRaiders81
                            Raidaas Fans Watch Will and Grace
                            • Mar 2005
                            • 2196

                            #14
                            Peyton didn't choke. NE's defense was just dominating. Indy's considered a offensive team, NE is considered a All-around team. I'm just saying if Peyton played on a all-around team, he'd probaly have a SB by now.
                            The Houston Retro Raiders.

                            Comment

                            • gobuffalo2007
                              All-Pro Zoner
                              • Mar 2005
                              • 1333

                              #15
                              Originally posted by Sportsuser101
                              1 Peyton Manning
                              2 Tom Brady
                              3 Daunte Culpepper
                              4 Matt Hasslebeck
                              5 Donovan McNabb
                              6 Drew Brees
                              7 Brett Favre
                              8 Steve McNair
                              9 Marc Bulger
                              10 Michael Vick

                              Comments?
                              Hasslebeck??????!!!!!!
                              here is mine.

                              1.J.P.
                              2.Losman
                              3.J to the P losman
                              4.J.P. Losman
                              5.J.P. Losman
                              6.J.P. Losman
                              7.J.P. Losman
                              8.J.P. Losman
                              9.J.P. Losman
                              10.J.P. Losman

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X