How bad do you want Andrew Luck?

[DraftBoy]

There has been a lot of talk in the last 24 hours about Luck and how badly some zoners want him. This was fueled in the last 30 mins by X-Era posting a quote from Michael Lombardi stating he hears that Carolina at #1 is not looking at a QB.

So let's say they are looking to trade down. How much would you pay for Andrew Luck?

[X-Era]

There has been a lot of talk in the last 24 hours about Luck and how badly some zoners want him. This was fueled in the last 30 mins by X-Era posting a quote from Michael Lombardi stating he hears that Carolina at #1 is not looking at a QB.

So let's say they are looking to trade down. How much would you pay for Andrew Luck?

I had to go trade chart only because there was no option for slightly less than trade chart value, or for a pick and player. I think either may be possible.

This should be an interesting poll.

[DraftBoy]

I had to go trade chart only because there was no option for slightly less than trade chart value, or for a pick and player. I think either may be possible.

This should be an interesting poll.

I didnt allow for those because the player option carries too many variables and nobody in their right mind would accept less than trade chart value.

[Dr. Lecter]

http://walterfootball.com/draftchart.php

Here is a link to the chart for the Google impaired.

[RockStar36]

I wouldn't 'Ricky Williams' the draft for him, but almost anything else is fair game.

Thanks to Lecter for posting that chart. I have to say trade chart value because that is more than fair to Carolina, especially if they aren't looking at him anyways. Whoever they'd want besides him will most likely be there at 3.

[X-Era]

I didnt allow for those because the player option carries too many variables and nobody in their right mind would accept less than trade chart value.

Ok.

BTW, wasn't the chart revised a few years back to lessen the value of the top picks? For some reason it seems unchanged everywhere I looked.

[DraftBoy]

I wouldn't 'Ricky Williams' the draft for him, but almost anything else is fair game.

Thanks to Lecter for posting that chart. I have to say trade chart value because that is more than fair to Carolina, especially if they aren't looking at him anyways. Whoever they'd want besides him will most likely be there at 3.

Who cares if they want him or not? Based on some reports this kid is the best prospect since Manning.

If you're Carolina you're only going to take value for him?

[Bangarang]

Maybin for their 1st straight up. We're getting robbed on this one but it'd be worth it in the long run.

[Mr. Miyagi]

I'd be willing to give up a lot for this kid.

[Dr. Lecter]

I would go over the chart - one or two picks - because Luck is special (and not justa "special")

[ZAZusmc03]

I'd give them slightly more than chart value. The kid is freaking good and I would love to see him as a bill. But I also don't want to put too much of a dent in the rebuilding process.

[X-Era]

I would go over the chart - one or two picks - because Luck is special (and not justa "special")

I'd prefer to push one of the picks required for the trade off until 2012... we all know the world will end then anyways.

[SquishDaFish]

Id go over by 1 pick. Do almost whatever it would take without a Rickey Williams situation or next years #1

[X-Era]

I'd give them slightly more than chart value. The kid is freaking good and I would love to see him as a bill. But I also don't want to put too much of a dent in the rebuilding process.

Nor do I. I simply see other avenues like a few more free agents than usual.

[YardRat]

Let the bidding war begin, and IMO the price will be driven too high.

Pass.

[Nighthawk]

I would go over the chart - one or two picks - because Luck is special (and not justa "special")

The Bills NEED this kid and they need a new, up and coming face for this organization.

[Nighthawk]

Let the bidding war begin, and IMO the price will be driven too high.

Pass.

I'm sorry, but you're not thinking clearly. Let's put it this way...if you had a chance to trade for the 1st pick in the 1998 draft to get Manning, would you? Well, I'm sure I can guess your answer and this kid is being compared to him and his talent level.

[DraftBoy]

I'm sorry, but you're not thinking clearly. Let's put it this way...if you had a chance to trade for the 1st pick in the 1998 draft to get Manning, would you? Well, I'm sure I can guess your answer and this kid is being compared to him and his talent level.

You havent voted yet, what are you willing to do?

[X-Era]

So far the vast majority is in favor of trading up and paying at least what the value chart dictates.

[ZAZusmc03]

Nor do I. I simply see other avenues like a few more free agents than usual.

I agree completely. If we give up several picks from this years draft, then we hit fa hard for d help.