I'd rather have QB like Manning that consistently gets his team into the playoffs (also owns or shares many NFL passing records), than a QB that can barely complete 50% of his passes. If Tebow didn't talk about religion and faith every 5 seconds, he would have already gone the way of Eric Crouch.
I would rather have a QB like Tebow or Eli Manning that WINS playoff games than Peyton who CHOKES.Originally Posted by jlgarsh
So now you're comparing two Superbowls to one playoff win?
Generalissimus Gibby (01-13-2013),mikemac2001 (01-13-2013),Novacane (01-13-2013)
No, I'm comparing Eli's Super Bowls to his brother Peyton's. And Tebow's playoff record with the Broncos to Peyton's playoff record with the Broncos.
Even sadder than the Losman licker crowd.
Generalissimus Gibby (01-13-2013),Novacane (01-13-2013)
My guess is when the years pass, Payton will have his bust in Hall of Fame, while the only thing Tebow will have in the Hall of Fame is a hot dog and coke in the cafeteria, after he pays the price of admission to get in.
Generalissimus Gibby (01-13-2013)
so... payton making 2 superbowls, winning 1 is choaking... manning making the playoffs 9 straight seasons as a starter is choking... payton winning 10 or more games in all, but 2 nfl season is choking...
listen, i was not a fan of Payton for a chunk of his career, but his last superbowl run converted me. That year was easily the best play by a QB i've ever seen.
My wife told me that if I had a dollar for every girl who found me unattractive, girls would find me VERY attractive.
MY WIFE SAID THAT!!!
BertSquirtgum (01-13-2013),jlgarsh (01-13-2013),Novacane (01-13-2013)
The Broncos choke on D to give up an incredibly bad late TD....and this is MANNING ??? Really ?
BertSquirtgum (01-13-2013),jlgarsh (01-13-2013)
It helped a bunch that an Indy defense finally decided to show up during that run. What happened every other year? Crucial picks.
The defense was terrible, and Fox/McCoy turtled-up at critical times. Is it all Manning's fault? Of course not, not even most, but the guy's career m.o. is not being able to come through in the clutch when it's win or go home. Peyton is a HOF regular season/statistics quarterback just like Marino and Fouts.
YardRat Wall of Fame
#56 DARRYL TALLEY #29 DERRICK BURROUGHS#22 FRED JACKSON #95 KYLE WILLIAMS
Slick (01-13-2013)
Just an adder on Manning...the one year Indy brought home a ring, Peyton actually had one of his worst post-season's of his career (the worst if you eliminate a couple of one-and-dones in '99 and '02 where he really **** the bed)....6.76 ypa, 3 TDs, 7 ints, and a rating of only 70.5.
http://espn.go.com/nfl/player/stats/...peyton-manning
Slick (01-13-2013)
Manning gave up 14 points in the first half of the game with INTS & threw an int in overtime to LOSE the game. Manning CHOKED.
And 14 Bronco points were scored by special teams, NOT Manning.
Slick (01-13-2013)
This frees up Peyton for the Pro Bowl.
Patti
He only had two picks one in first half and one at the end....so idk how that ='s 2 in first half
also doesnt matter he drove his team down took the lead....and a 70 yard TD bomb with 40 secs left are u ****ing kidding me that **** doesnt happen...that was a joke if that happened to us this board would be blowing up
MUCK
FIAMI
jlgarsh (01-13-2013)
Oh, I think the discussion would be similar....just look back on some of the threads after a Bills loss and Fitz threw a late-game interception. God knows there is enough of them.
Peyton Manning playoff record: 9-11 CHOKE
Super Bowl Ring
your just a hater and its obvious
Well, his younger brother has TWO rings & a much better playoff record.
At least you're smart enough to drop the Tebow part of your argument. If this is strickly a Manning - Manning debate then it's worth a discussion.
Generalissimus Gibby (01-13-2013),jlgarsh (01-13-2013),Novacane (01-13-2013)
and if you think that Denver would have able to put up 35 points with Tebow at the helm yesterday is absurd. Even thinking he could come up with 21 is debatable. As look http://www.pro-football-reference.co...oTi00/gamelog/ at his game log and you'll notice in most of his wins it was his defense holding the opposition to below twenty points or less that helped paved the way to a win.
Generalissimus Gibby (01-13-2013)
Good idea for a thread:
Who is the better Manning: Archie, Peyton, Eli
Who is the better QB: Brady or Manning
Who is the greatest QB in Colts history: John Unitas or Peyton Manning
****tard idea for a thread:
Who is a better qb: 1-1 Tim who will be in the Pulpit in five year Tebow who is a glorified RB or one of the greatest qbs in the history of the game. Damn, there is just so much fail in this thread
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote